105.Shiroishi Castle Part1

Each independent lord was not allowed to have castles, excluding the only one the lord lived in, by the shogunate. However, Shiroishi Castle, where the Katakura Clan as a retainer lived in, remained as an exemption. This was probably due to Date’s strong influence as well as Katakura’s contributions.

Location and History

Castle owned by Katakura Clan, Senior Vassal of Date Clan

Shiroishi Castle is located in modern day Shiroishi City at the southern edge of Miyagi Prefecture. It was also located in the southern edge of the Date Clan’s territory during the Edo Period. The lords of the clan had the area around the castle being governed by their trusted senior vassal family, the Katakura Clan all through the period. The castle had a three level turret called the Large Turret which was actually equivalent to the Main Tower. That’s why the castle looked like a symbol of an independent lord.

The range of MIyagi Prefecture, the range of the Sendai Domain was larger than the prefecture

The restored Main Tower of Matsumoto Castle

The founder of the Katakura Clan, Kagetsuna Katakura served his master, Masamune Date from his childhood because Kagetsuna’s older sister, Kita became Masamune’s foster mother. Since then, Kagetsuna contributed to Masamune becoming the greatest warlord in the Tohoku Region during the late 16th Century by joining many battles and being a diplomatic agent with other warlords. When the ruler, Hideyoshi Toyotomi invaded the Kanto Region to complete his unification of Japan in 1590, Masamune was wondering if he should follow Hideyoshi or not. Kagetsuna advised Masamune to do so, and as a result, they were able to survive. Masamune eventually gave Kagetsuna the important Shiroishi area in 1602 after the Date Clan’s territory was fixed as the Sendai Domain by the Tokugawa Shogunate.

The portrait of Kagetsuna Katakura, owned by Sendai City Museum (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The portrait of Masamune Date, owned by Sendai City Museum (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Kagetsuna’s son, Shigenaga was very active in the summer campaign of the Siege of Osaka in 1615 where the shogunate defeated the Toyotomi Clan. There is a heroic story about him and his rival, Nobushige Sanada. They once fought each other in the battle, but Nobushige sent a letter (affixed to an arrow) to Shigenaga, which asked him to accommodate Nobushige’s children before his death. Kagetsuna accepted it, and then, Oume, Nobushige’s daughter would be Shigenaga’s second wife and another son, Daihachi would be a retainer of the Sendai Domain. One theory seems to be that Shigenaga took Oume away from Osaka Castle when it was falling and accommodated the other children when they later visited her in Shiroishi Castle. In either case, Shigenaga must have been a man of great capacity.

The portrait of Shigenaga Katakura, drawn in a Ukiyoe-painting, attributed to Yoshiiku Ochiai (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The summer campaign of the siege of Osaka folding screens, owned by Osaka Castle Museum (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The portrait of Nobushige Sanada, owned by Ueda City Museum (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Castle survives as exemption of One Castle per Province

Shigenaga’s successor, Kagenaga was also important for the domain. When an internal trouble of the Date Clan, called Date-sodo (feud), happened in 1671, the government of the domain got out of control due to a bloody affair at the shogunate court in Edo. Kagenaga stayed local to keep other retainers calm and kept the government. These events were decisive for the position of the Katakura Clan. In addition, each independent lord was not allowed to have castles, excluding the only one the lord lived in, by the shogunate. However, Shiroishi Castle, where the Katakura Clan as a retainer lived in, remained as an exemption. This was probably due to Date’s strong influence as well as Katakura’s contributions.

The ruins of Sendai Castle, the home of the Date Clan

Castle is completed by Gamo and Katakura Clans

As for Shiroishi Castle itself, it is uncertain when it was first built, but it was considered an important strategic location for transportation. After the unification of Japan by Hideyoshi Toyotomi, Satonari Gamo, a senior vassal of the clan owned and modernized the castle by building stone walls and the Main Tower. He would later improve several other castles like Kasama Castle, which can be seen as a hidden master of castle constructions. The Katakura Clan lived and improved the castle more based on the essential structures Satonari built.

The ruins of Kasama Castle

The castle had several enclosures on a hill. The Main Enclosure on the top had the main buildings of the castle, such as the three-level Main Tower, Main Gate, Back Gate, Main Hall, and two two-level turrets. They were exactly the same items as what other independent lords had. However, the Main Hall also had an interesting feature. The hall had two front entrances, one for locals and the other only for the lord of the Date Clan, the master of the Katakura Clan. The hall also had the rooms, called Onari-goten, where only the lord could stay.

The miniature model of Kasama Castle, exhibited by Shiroishi Castle History Museum
The miniature model of the main enclosure of Shiroishi Castle
The part of the Main Hall in the miniature model above, the entrance for the locals is marked by the blue circle and that only for the lord of the domain is marked by the red circle

The Katakura Clan also developed the castle town below the hill, where the retainers and other citizens lived in. Waterways were also developed in the town for defensive purposes and living. For example, there were Samurai residences in the Third Enclosure, part of the town, which was surrounded by the Sawabata River and the waterways. The residences were relatively smaller than other residences of independent domains. This was because the retainers under the Katakura Clan had lower incomes than those who served independent lords.

Part of the Illustration of Shiroishi Castle in the Sendai Domain, Oshu Region, the third enclosure along the Sawabata River is in the front, exhibited by the National Archives of Japan
The remaining Samurai residence along the Sawabata River

One of stages of Meiji Restoration

In 1868 during the Meiji Restoration, an important event happened to the castle again. Many domains against the New Government in the Tohoku Region held the Shiroishi Meeting in the castle. This was because the Sendai Domain was their leader and the castle could also be a hub for them. This event would be the trigger for the Boshin War between the government and the domains. However, the castle was eventually opened as its real master, the Sendai Domain had surrendered to the government.

The current Shiroishi Castle

To be continued in “Shiroishi Castle Part2”

116.沼田城(Numata Castle)

沼田城は真田がこだわり続け、しかし最後には失った城です。
Numata Castle is the one that Sanada stuck to strongly, but lost in the end.

沼田城西櫓跡(The ruins of Nishi-Yagura of Numata Castle)

Location and History

群馬県の北部に位置する沼田市は、全国的に河岸段丘の地形で有名です。その高さは、JR沼田駅近くの利根川から70メートル以上になります。市街地はその段丘の上にあり、「天空の城下町」と呼ばれています。
Numata City, in the northern part of Gunma pref., is famous around the whole country for its terrain with river terraces. The height is over 70m higher than Tone River near the JR Numata Station. The urban area of the city is on the top of the terraces and now called “Castle Town in the Sky”.

沼田市の河岸段丘、左側が段状になっている(The river terraces in Numata City, they are on the left side)taken by igamania from photo AC

この辺り一帯が最初に注目されたのは恐らく、戦国時代の16世紀頃、関東地方の支配権を巡って戦った上杉、北条、武田、織田、徳川などの有力戦国大名たちによってだと思われます。沼田地域は、関東地方の北の入り口にあたり、東の東北地方から西の信濃国(現在の長野県)に抜けていく主要街道が通っていました。
The area was probably first focused on in the Warring States Period in the 16th century by major warlords such as the Uesugi, Hojo, Takeda, Oda and Tokugawa clans who battled over the right to rule of the Kanto region . The Numata area was the northern entrance of Kanto and had a main road passing through from the east for Tohoku region to the west for Shinano Province (now Nagano pref.).

城周辺の地図及び起伏地図(A normal and relief map around Numata Castle)



沼田城は最初、土豪の沼田氏によって1532年に段丘の突端に築かれました。しかし、1560年の上杉氏の関東侵攻からは非常に重要な拠点として認識されました。結果的には、戦国時代の終わりにおいては武田氏配下の真田昌幸がこの城を保持していました。1582年には彼の主君である武田氏は滅びてしまうのですが、他の有力大名を差し置いて何とか城を守り抜きました。
Numata Castle was first built on the tip of the terrace in 1532 by the local clan Numata, but the castle became a very important site after the Uesugi’s Kanto invasion in 1560. Eventually, Masayuki Sanada under Takeda held the castle at the end of the Warring States Period. Though his master Takeda was beaten in 1582, he struggled against other major warlords to keep the castle.

真田昌幸像、個人蔵(The portlait of Masayuki Sanada, privately owned)licensed under Public Domain, via Wikimedia Commons

クライマックスは、1589年に天下人豊臣秀吉の裁断によって、この城が北条氏に引き渡されたときでした。何と真田は、1590年の秀吉の関東侵攻と、北条氏の滅亡により、城の奪還に成功します。この出来事は、北条が約束を破り、真田の名胡桃城を乗っ取ったからだと言われていますが、真相は謎のままです。死人に口なしだからです。
The climax was that the castle was turned over to Hojo in 1589 by the decision of the ruler, Hideyoshi Toyotomi. However, Sanada was successful to get it back after Toyotomi’s Kanto invasion and the fall of Hojo in 1590. It is said that the event was caused due to Hojo breaking the rule and taking Sanada’s Nagurumi Castle. The fact is mysterious because dead men tell no tales.

名胡桃城跡(The ruins of Nagurumi Castle)licensed by Qurren via Wikimedia Commons

その後、昌幸の息子、真田信之が徳川の下につき、この城を引き継ぎ1600年前後に天守の建築を含め完成させました。この天守は、将軍がいる江戸城を除いては関東地方で唯一の5層の天守でした。
After that, Masayuki’s son Nobuyuki Sanada under Tokugawa inherited and completed the castle with building the castle Tenshu keep around 1600. The Tenshu was the only five-story one in Kanto region, excluding Edo Castle owned by the Shogun.

上野国沼田城絵図部分、江戸時代(Part of the illustration of Numata Castle in Kozuke Province in Edo Period)|出典:国立公文書館

1658年に、真田一族の中でこの城の相続を巡ってお家騒動が起こりました。徳川幕府は、真田の分家である信利を沼田藩として、信濃国松代にあった真田本家より独立させる決定をしました。
There was internal trouble in the Sanada clan over the inheritance of the castle in 1658. The Tokugawa Shogunate decided to make the branch Sanada, Nobutoshi separate from the head Sanada in Matsushiro, Sinano Province as the Numata Domain.

真田信利肖像画、加納永泰筆、大法院蔵(The Portrait of Nobutoshi Sanada, attributed to Eitai Kano, ownd by Daihoin)licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons

信利は、幕府から困難な課役を引き受け、真田本家に対抗するため豪華な屋敷も造営しました。その結果沼田藩の領民は重い年貢に苦しみました。そして信利は、両国橋再建の資材調達に失敗したのと、農民の茂左衛門の幕府への直訴により、1681年に改易となってしまいました。ついには、真田があれほどまでこだわった沼田城は、1682年に幕府により完全に破壊されたのです。
Nobutoshi accepted hard tasks from Shogunate and built luxurious halls against the head Sanada. The result was that people in Numata Domain suffered from high taxes. Nobutoshi was fired in 1681 inspired by his failure of preparing materials for the Ryogoku Bridge rebuilding and the direct appeal to Shogunate by a farmer called Mozaemon. At last, Numata Castle that Sanada were so much devoted to, was completely destroyed by Shogunate in 1682.

天守があったと思われる場所(The place where there seemed be Tenshu)

Features

現在沼田城の城跡は、沼田公園として使われています。そこには美しい花々や木々による庭園があるのですが、西櫓の石垣が掘り出されたのと、復元された時計台が残っているのみです。
Now, the ruins of Numata castle have been turned into a park called the Numata Park. Though it has a beautiful flowers and trees garden, only unearthed stone walls of the west turret and the restored clock tower remain.

沼田公園(Numata Park)
掘り出された西櫓石垣(The unearthen stone walls of the west turret)
復元された時計台(The restored clock tower)

Later Life

真田の城が撤去された後、土岐氏などの大名が江戸時代の間この地域を支配しましたが、藩庁のための建物が設置されたのみでした。明治維新後その建物も撤去され、堀は埋められました。幸いだったのは元藩士の久米民之助が城跡を買い上げ、市に公園として寄付したことでした。
After Sanada’s castle was demolished, some lords like the Toki clan governed the area in the Edo Period. They just had a few office halls to govern. After the Meiji Restoration, the buildings of the castle were removed, and moats were filled. The good thing was that a former warrior Taminosuke Kume bought the ruins and donated them to the city for a park.

公園からの眺め(A view from the park)

現在、2016年に人気が出たNHK大河ドラマ「真田丸」が放送された後、沼田市には天守を復元できないか検討している人たちがいます。そのドラマは、真田氏、主には信之の弟、真田信繁の人生を描いたもので、信繁は大坂城で豊臣のために徳川と戦ったことで有名です。(真田氏は意図的に徳川方と豊臣方に分かれていました。)ドラマでは、沼田も取り上げられており、そのことが沼田市の観光振興にも寄与しました。
Now, some people in this city are considering how they could restore the Tenshu after a popular NHK drama called “Sanada-Maru” aired in Japan in 2016. The drama was about the lives of the Sanada clan, mainly about Nobushige Sanada, Nobuyuki’s little brother, famous for the fights with Tokugawa for Toyotomi in Osaka Castle. (Sanada clan were divided into Tokugawa and Toyotomi on purpose.) The drama which also featured Numata, led to an increase in tourism for the city.

現地案内板にある天守の想像図(The imaginary drawing of Tenshu on the sign board at the site)

市の人たちは、近い将来に人気が衰えてしまうのを心配しているようです。そして天守のような新しいシンボルを模索しており、白石城のような成功事例を視察したりしています。
People in the city seem worried about the decrease in the near future. They are searching for a new symbol like the Tenshu, and researching successful cases such as the Shiroishi Castle.

復元された白石城(The restored Shiroishi Castle)

しかしながら実現にはいくつもの大きな問題があります。まず、早々に城が破壊されたため天守の詳細が全くわかりません。現在のところ本丸石垣と、金箔瓦や什器などいくつかの品が発掘されたのみです。加えて文化庁が各地方自治体に明確な根拠なしに歴史的建造物を安易に復元しないよう指導している事情もあります。次として莫大な予算が必要です。もし天守を伝統的木造建築のスタイルで再建する場合、市の年間一般会計予算に匹敵する資金が必要となります。実に悩ましい問題です。
However, there will be big problems that come with it. At first, the details are not clear at all because of the castle being destroyed. Stone walls of Honmaru, and few items like roof tiles with gold leaf and utensils have been excavated so far. In addition, the Agency for Cultural Affairs instructs local governments not to restore historical buildings without clear evidence. Secondly it needs a large budget. If they ever decide to construct the Tenshu in a traditional wooden style, it will require a fund as much as their annual general budget. That is too controversial.

発掘された本丸石垣(The excavated stone walls of Honmaru)

市は、自らを「真田の里」として売り出しています。これからどんな展開になるか注目したいと思います。
The city is also trying to identify itself as “Sanada’s Hometown”. I will keep watching what they are doing now.

My Impression

人気を維持するためまず考えられるのは、大坂城上田城、名胡桃城、岩櫃城など真田にまつわる城や城跡を持つ自治体と連携してイベントを開くことだと思います。
To keep the population, I think that a reasonable idea is holding events together with other municipalities having relative castles and ruins to Sanada such as Osaka, Ueda, Nagurumi and Iwabitsu.

大坂城(Osaka Castle)
上田城(Ueda Castle)

そして、可能性がある方法としては、発掘の結果を基に門か櫓を再建することです。例えば、鉢形城などが類似のケースでしょう。
Then, one possible solution could be rebuilding a gate or a turret based on excavation. There are similar cases, for example in Hachigata.

鉢形城の再建された門(The rebuilt gate in Hachigata Castle)

もう一つの可能性として、大分府内城のようにLEDを使って仮想天守の姿を創り出してはいかがでしょう。
For another possibility, how about creating the image of virtual Tenshu with LED like Oita-Funai.

大分府内城の仮想天守(The virtual Tenchu in Oita-Funai Castle)taken by ぴょんにゃん from photo AC

But if they actually want to construct a real Tenshu building, they might have to be prepared for using it as their office hall.
でも、もし本当に本物の天守を作りたいのであれば、市役所の建物に使うくらいの覚悟が必要なのではないでしょうか。

How to get There

沼田城跡に行くには車が便利です。関越自動車道の沼田ICから約10分です。電車を使う場合は、JR沼田駅から歩いて約20分かかります。河岸段丘の急坂を登っていく必要がありますが、それも面白いかもしれません。
東京から沼田駅まで:上越新幹線に乗って高崎まで行き、上越線に乗り換えてください。
It is useful to access Numata Castle Ruins by car. It takes about 10 minutes from Numata IC on Kan-Etsu Expressway. When using train, it takes about 20 minutes on foot from JR Numata Station. It needs to climb up a steep hill on the river terraces, but it may be interesting.
From Tokyo to Numata Station: Take the Jo-Etsu Shinkansen super express to Takasaki, then transfer to Jo-Etsu local line.

Links and References

沼田市観光協会(Numata Tourism Association)
・沼田市議会新政同志会平成29年第1回会派調査・研修報告(Japanese Document)