124.Shinagawa Batteries Part1

The arrival of Matthew Perry’s fleet from the U.S. in 1853 gave a big impact on the shogunate’s policy. The shogunate ordered Hidetatsu Egawa to build the certain defensive system in Edo Bay immediately before Perry’s second arrival.

Location and History

Perry’s Arrival leads Construction of Batteries

The map around Tokyo Bay

Odaiba is one of the popular tourist spots in the waterfront area of Tokyo. The land’s name directly means the honorific of batteries and originates from Shinagawa Batteries which were built by the Tokugawa Shogunate to protect Edo City during the end of the Edo Period. The area still has a few of the ruins of the batteries.

Odaiba Seaside Prak, you can see the ruins of No.3 Battery in the sea

When Western ships often appeared around Japan at that time, the shogunate ordered some feudal domain lords and its own divisions to protect the inside and outside of Edo Bay (the current Tokyo Bay) from possible invasions by the ships. However, they were actually not able to protect even the 8km wide Uraga Channel, the mouth of the bay by their batteries because they didn’t have Blue water navy due to their isolationism. That’s why the shogunate’s basic policy of how to treat the Western ships coming to Japan was to hear their purposes, give materials they needed, and persuade them to return their countries. Therefore, the first arrival of Matthew Perry’s fleet from the U.S. in 1853 gave a big impact on the shogunate’s policy. His fleet intentionally broke the line of the bay mouth and demonstrated its power in the bay to ask the shogunate to open the country.

The mouth of the bay, seen from Kanaya Port at Boso Peninsula
Matthew Perry, around 1856 to 1858 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The monument of Perry’s landing in Kurihama Coast at Miura Peninsula

Hidetatu Egawa builds Batteries at Sea off Shinagawa

After that, the shogunate ordered Hidetatsu Egawa who was an excellent official and learned the Western sciences to build the certain defensive system in Edo Bay immediately before Perry’s second arrival. Hidetatsu thought it would be the priority to build the final protective line for the Shogun’s Edo Castle and the city area, about 2km off the coast beside the Shinagawa Post Station. The line would consist of several batteries in coastal castles which would bring a cross fire to enemies’ ships. Another reason for the location was that the coastal area was too shallow that the large Western battle ships, like Perry’s flag ship, Susquehanna, would not be able to enter it. In addition, the batteries were out of their range, therefore, they would only be able to confront with gun boats.

The self -portrait of Hidetatsu Egawa (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The final protective line drawn in “The Illustration of Shinagawa Batteries”, exhibited by Tokyo Metropolitan Library
Susquehanna, the flag ship of the 1853 Perry’s fleet (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

The number of the batteries in the original plan was 11 and the first three ones (No.1 to 3) were completed within a year before Perry’s return, which would be called Shinagawa Batteries. Each battery was on an artificial isolated square island which was surrounded by stone walls and equipped with cannons and related items, which were generally called redoubts. The basic design of the batteries came from several books of the Western military sciences which Hidetatsu and his staff translated. The canons were provided domestically by emulating the Western canons’ designs. However, some of them were cast iron canons the Saga Domain had just succeeded in producing, which were close to the worldwide level. The stone walls were built in the Japanese style, but the top of them was built using a new method called Hanedashi which emulated the European castles. In addition, one of the original ideas for the batteries was to build breakwater piles around them. They would also be used to prevent enemies’ gun boats from getting close to the batteries.

The specification drawing of No.3 Battery in Shinagawa Batteries, Edo Bay, exhibited by Tokyo Metropolitan Library
A bronze cannon used in a Shinagawa battery, exhibited by Yushukan Meseum
The Hanedashi system seen in No.3 Battery
The breakwater piles in the specification drawing above

System is maintained until End of Edo Period

The shogunate concluded a treaty with Perry in 1854, known as the Japan–US Treaty of Peace and Amity. The constructions of Shinagawa Batteries continued, but only five (No.1 to 3, 5 and 6) out of the planned 11 were completed and 2 (No.4 and 7) out of 11 were canceled in the middle of their constructions. The reason for it was the shortage of the budget and the stabilization of the diplomatic relationship with the Western Countries after the treaty. The operations of the batteries were done by warriors from several feudal domains. For example, the Oshi Domain, which was based in Oshi Castle, was in charge of the No.3 Battery. The warriors went to the isolated sea battery by using small boats and stayed in the barrack inside with no baths until the next team came.

The current No.3 Battery

The shogunate also thought the defense system was still not enough. It built coast batteries instead of the uncompleted sea batteries, such as the Battery below Goten-yama Mountain, to support the completed sea batteries. It also built their own gun boats to work closely with these batteries. Each sea battery had its pier where the boats were able to stop. The operation of the defense line lasted until 1868 when the shogunate was defeated by the New Government, known as the Meiji Restoration.

The aerial photo around the batteries around 1945 to 1950, the grounds for them remained until then

The ruins of the Battery below Goten-yama Mountain, located around the past coastline
The tier of the No.6 Battery which may be similar to the original

The evaluation of Shinagawa Batteries may be difficult because they were actually not used for battles and the specs of the cannons installed in the batteries became obsolete quickly. However, historians say the batteries worked as a deterrence for invasion by the Western countries. They pointed out that the qualities of the canons in the batteries were at the same level as those equipped in Perry’s fleet. A diplomat from the U.K., who saw the batteries, reported to his government that the batteries had technology levels which were equivalent to the Western cannons.

Shinagawa Batteries drawn in a Ukiyoe-painting called Takanawa Shugetsu (meaning Autumn Moon in Takanawa), attributed to Hiroshige Utagawa the second, exhibited by Tokyo Metropolitan Library

To be continued in “Shinagawa Batteries Part2”

124.品川台場 その1

1853年のマシュー・ペリー率いるアメリカ艦隊の来航は、幕府の根本政策に大きな衝撃を与えました。幕府は江川英龍に、ペリーの2度目の来航の前に、江戸湾に確固とした防衛システムを速やかに構築するよう命じました。

立地と歴史

ペリー艦隊の来航がきっかけ

お台場は東京のウォーターフロントエリアの人気の観光地の一つです。この地の名前は、直接には「台場」に敬称の「御」を付けたものであり、江戸時代末期に武家の都である江戸防衛のため、徳川幕府により築かれた品川台場を由来としています。この地区には今でもわずかではありますが、台場の遺跡が残っています。

東京湾周辺の地図

お台場海浜公園、沖に見えるのが三番台場跡

当時日本周辺に西洋船が頻繁に出没するようになると、幕府はいくつかの譜代大名と幕下の部署に、西洋船による侵攻の恐れから江戸湾(現東京湾)内外を防衛するよう命じました。ところが実際には、その当時の大砲では江戸湾の入口である僅か8km幅の浦賀水道でさえ防衛することができませんでした。幕府は自らの鎖国政策のため、遠洋艦隊を持っていなかったからです。そのため、日本にやってきた西洋船に対する幕府の基本的対応は、来航の目的を聞き、必要な物資を与えた上で退去するよう説得するというものでした。したがって、1853年のマシュー・ペリー率いるアメリカ艦隊の来航は、幕府の根本政策に大きな衝撃を与えました。ペリー艦隊は意図的に江戸湾口を突破し、幕府に開国を迫るため湾内を示威的に航行したのです。

房総半島の金谷港から見た江戸湾口
マシュー・ペリー、1856年~1858年頃  (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
三浦半島久里浜にあるペリー上陸記念碑

江川英龍が品川沖に砲台を建造

その後幕府は江川英龍(えがわひでたつ)に対して、ペリーの2度目の来航の前に、江戸湾に確固とした防衛システムを速やかに構築するよう命じました。英龍は優秀な官僚であり、西洋科学を学んでいました。彼は、最終防衛線として江戸城と江戸市中を守ることが最優先であると考えました。その場所は、品川宿近くの、海岸線から約2km沖合でした。防衛線は、海上にあるいくつもの砲台から成り、敵方の船に十字砲火を浴びせられるようになっていました。この立地を選んだもう一つの理由は、この海岸沿いの海は水深が浅く、ペリー艦隊の旗艦、サスケハナ号のような大型の西洋軍艦は乗り入れることができなかったことです。また、砲台群はこれら大型船の大砲の射程外であり、この海域に入ってこられる小型砲艦のみに対応すればよいという有利な状況もありました。

江川英龍自画像  (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
「品川台場絵図」に描かれた品川台場による防衛ライン、出典:東京都立図書館
1853年のペリー艦隊の旗艦、サスケハナ号 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

当初の計画では11か所の砲台を築くとされ、一番から三番までの3つの砲台が、ペリー再来航の前の7ヶ月以内に運用を開始し、品川台場と呼ばれるようになりました。それぞれの台場は四角い人工の孤島であり、石垣に囲まれ、大砲と関連施設を備えていました。専門的には方形堡と言われます。台場の基本設計は、英龍や部下たちが翻訳した西洋の兵学書に基づいていました。台場で使われていた大砲は、西洋製を模倣した国産によって賄われていました。しかし、その中には佐賀藩がちょうど製造に成功したばかりの鋳鉄製の大砲が含まれていて、世界の最先端のレベルに迫っていました。台場の石垣は、従来の日本式で築かれていましたが、その最上段は跳ね出しというヨーロッパの城郭に倣った方式を採用していました。また、これら台場独自で考え出されたアイデアの一つとして、周囲に波除杭を敷設したことがあります。これらは本来の用途の他に、敵の砲艦の台場への接近を防ぐという効果もありました。

「江戸品川御臺場仕様図面(三番御臺場圖)」、出典:東京都立図書館
品川台場で用いられた日本製青銅砲、靖国神社遊就館にて展示
三番台場の跳ね出し石垣
上記図面に描かれた波除杭

幕末まで維持された防衛システム

幕府は1854年に開国を決断し、ペリーとの間で日米和親条約を結びます。品川台場の建設は続きましたが、計画された11基のうち、5基のみ(一番~三番、五番、六番)のみが完成し、2基(四番、七番)は建設途中で中止となりました。その理由としては、予算不足と、条約後の西洋諸国との外交関係が安定したことが挙げられます。台場の運営は、いくつかの藩から武士たちが派遣されて行われました。例えば、忍城を本拠とする忍藩は三番台場を受け持っていました。武士たちは小さな舟に乗って独立した海堡まで行き、次の組が来るまで風呂なしの兵舎で待機していました。

現在の3番台場

幕府はまた、この防衛システムが不十分とも考えていました。未完成に終わった海上砲台の代わりに、御殿山下砲台のような海岸砲台を築きました。更には、独自の砲艦を建造し、これらの砲台と緊密な連携が取れるようにしました。それぞれの台場には船着き場があり、砲艦が停泊できるようになっていました。この防衛ラインの運用は、1868年に幕府が新政府によって倒される明治維新のときまで続きました。

1945年~1950年頃の品川台場周辺の航空写真、まだ各台場の敷地は残っていました

御殿山下砲台跡、かつての海岸線辺りにあります
オリジナルに近い6番台場の船着き場周辺

品川台場の評価は難しいかもしれません。実際の戦いに使われたことはなく、台場に設置された大砲の性能は急速に陳腐化してしまったからです。しかし歴史家は、西洋諸国による侵略を防ぐ抑止力として機能したのではないかと言っています。台場にあった大砲は、ペリー艦隊に搭載されていた大砲と同レベルであったと指摘されています。また、英国から派遣された外交官は、品川台場を見て、そこで使われている技術は西洋の大砲と同等のレベルであると本国に報告しています。

「江戸名所四十八景、三十五、高輪秋月」、二世歌川広重作、品川台場が描かれています、出典:東京都立図書館

「品川台場その2」に続きます。

今回の内容を趣向を変えて、Youtube にも投稿しました。よろしかったらご覧ください。

162.Izushi Castle/Arikoyama Castle Part1

The Izushi area is known as its old castle town where many people visit to enjoy walking, eating and shopping around the area including the Izushi Castle Ruins at the foot of the mountain. If you look up at the mountain on a fine day, you will find stone walls on the top, which are other castle ruins in this area, called Arikoyama Castle which had been built before Izushi Castle.

Location and History

Two Castle Ruins in Izushi Area

Izushi Castle is located in modern day in the Izushi area of Toyooka City in the northern part of Hyogo Prefecture. The area is known as the old castle town where many people visit to enjoy walking, eating and shopping around the area including the Izushi Castle Ruins at the foot of the mountain. If you look up at the mountain on a fine day, you will find stone walls on the top, which are other castle ruins in this area, called Arikoyama Castle which had been built before Izushi Castle. These things make you understand the area has a very long history and rich culture.

The range of Toyooka City and the location of the castles

A street of the old Izushi castle town
Izushi Castle Ruins in the front and Arikoyama Castle Ruins in the back
The zooemed stone walls on the mountain

Yamana Clan, One of Greatest Lords during Middle Ages

Arikoyama Castle was first built by the Yamana Clan which is known as one of the greatest lords during the Middle Ages. The clan was a branch family of the Nitta Clan, which came from the Kanto Region in eastern Japan. When the Ashikaga Shogunate was established, Tokiuji Yamana, who was the lord of the clan at that time, greatly supported Takauji Ashikaga, the founder of the shogunate. That’s why Takauji sent Tokiuji to the Sanin area, the northern part of the Chugoku Region to govern, where their enemies were still active. Tokiuji and his descendants conquered their territories by force and finally became the governors of 11 out of 66 provinces in Japan, called Rokubun-no-ichi-dono (meaning the Lord of One Sixth of Japan).

The family crest of the Yamana Clan (licensed by Houunji 1642 via Wikimedia Commons)
The 11 provinces the Yamana Clan became governors (the colored ones)  (licensed by ja:User:味っ子 via Wikimedia Commons)

However, Yoshimitsu Ashikaga, the third Shogun, was afraid of the overwhelming power of the Yamana Clan and defeated it in 1391, known as the Meitoku Rebellion. The clan’s power once declined but Sozen Yamana came out in the 15th Century and revived it as they had been. He is known as the commander in chief of the Western Alliance against the Eastern Alliance led by Katsumoto Hosokawa during the Onin War between 1467 and 1477 which would start the Sengoku Period. The clan eventually had many provinces again and its home was in the current Izushi area of Tajima Province which is now known as northern Hyogo Prefecture. The lords of the clan were first based in Konosumi-yama Castle on a mountain, about 5km north of the later Arikoyama Castle. Sozen actually made a sally with about 26 thousand warriors from this castle to fight with the Eastern Alliance in Kyoto.

The portrait of Sozen Yamana, from “Honcho-Hyakushoden” (licensed by Musuketeer.3 via Wikimedia Commons)
The portrait of Katsumoto Hosokawa, owned by Ryoanji Temple  (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Unlike the Hosokawa Clan which had a certain position in the central government, the Yamana Clan had to maintain its provinces by force. It got difficult for the clan to do it during the Sengoku Period when overthrowing their lords were often seen as overthrowing the whole country. The clan eventually lost its provinces one by one, being defeated in many battles against other warlords like the Akamatsu and Amago Clans. As a result, the Yamana’s authority decreased and some of its senior vassals tried to become independent. Suketoyo Yamana, the lord of the clan tried to somehow manage to maintain his last Tajima Province by building Takeda Castle near the border to other provinces, and asking greater warlords like the Oda and Mori Clans for help.

The range of Tajima Province and the location of the castles

The ruins of Takeda Castle

Suketoyo Yamana moves his home to Arikoyama Castle

However, when the Oda Clan attacked the Tajima Province in 1569, Suketomo’s home Konosumi-yama Castle was captured and he had to escape from the place. This might have been caused by the secret agreement between the Oda and Mori Clans that the Tajima Province would belong to the Oda. Suketoyo somehow returned to his territory in 1570 after he had met with Nobunaga Oda (the lord of the clan) while paying lots of money from mining in the province. Then, he moved to his home to Arikoyama Castle, located on a much higher and steeper mountain than Konosumi-yama Castle, and improved it so that the fall of his castle would never happen again. Suketomo usually lived in the residence at the foot of the mountain, which would be the origin of Izushi Castle and its castle town.

The portrait of Nobunaga Oda, attributed to Soshu Kano, owned by Chokoji Temple, in the late 16th century (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

The relief map around the castles

In the 1570’s, the Oda and Mori Clans began to oppose each other. Suketomo was debating on the face on which side he would support. The Oda Clan attacked the Tajima Province again in 1580 by sending Hidenaga Hashiba who was the little brother of Hideyoshi, the later ruler of Japan. It is said that one of the reasons for the invasion was that they wanted to own the mines in the province, such as the Ikuno Silver Mine. Hidenaga’s troops surrounded Arikoyama Castle and Suketomo finally had to surrender perhaps because they had no hope for reinforcements.

The portrait of Hidenaga Hashiba, owned by Shungakuin Temple (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Hidenaga Hashiba improves Castle

After that, Hidenaga lived in and improved the castle as the home base of the Tajima Province. The castle had been made of soil so far but its main portion on the top was fortified by building stone walls. It is said that Takatora Todo, who was a senior vassal of Hidenaga and would later become a master of castle constructions, built them. Senjoshiki (meaning the 1,000 mat enclosure), next to the main portion, was developed to accommodate many soldiers and supplies even when other lords in the province gathered for help.

The portrait of Takatora Todo, private owned (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The imaginary drawing of Arikoyama Castle, exhibited by Karo Yashiki Residence

Yoshihide Koide builds Izushi Castle

The castle was followed by the Koide Clan, a relative of Hideyoshi Toyotomi after he became the ruler of Japan. The clan somehow survived when the ruler was changed from the Toyotomi Clan to the Tokugawa Shogunate. In 1604, Yoshihide Koide renovated the foot residence and renamed it Izushi Castle perhaps due to the convenience for the government. He also abandoned Arikoyama Castle on the mountain instead. The new castle and its castle town prospered during the Edo Period as the Izushi Domain, which was finally followed by the Sengoku Clan until the end of the period.

The imaginary drawing of Izushi Castle, exhibited by Karo Yashiki Residence

To be continued in “Izushi Castle/Arikoyama Castle Part2”

error: Content is protected !!