156.Kamaha Castle Part1

A mountain castle with advanced systems

Location and History

Border Castle between Northern and Southern Omi Province

Kamaha Castle was a mountain castle during the Sengoku Period, which was located in Omi Provence (currently the modern day location of Shiga Prefecture). Its position was in the central area of the province, which at the time was divided into two parts, the northern part and the southern part. As a result, the two warlords from the Rokkaku Clan in the south and the warlord from the Azai Clan in the north were constantly gaining and loosing castles each other. Kamaha Castle was built on one of the ridges, which was 384 meters high, of Mt. Ryozen,. The name “Kamaha” which means “Sickle Blade” got its name from the shape of the ridge with its steep sides. The castle was located near a major road called “Nakasendo”, which was conveniently located for battle making it easier for transportation as well.

The range of Omi Province and the location of the castle

城周辺の起伏地図

In the middle of the 16th Century, during the Sengoku Period, the Hori Clan was the ruler of the castle. The clan frequently changed their masters depending on the situation. In one instance, back in 1553, the Rokkaku Clan attacked Kamaha Castle, forcing the Hori Clan to escape, eventually surrendering the castle completely. However, the Hori Clan would eventually form an allegiance with the Azai Clan, most likely because the Azai Clan was gaining a lot of power at that time. Back in 1570, The Azai Clan fought Nobunaga Oda, where Hidemura Hori sided with Nobunaga who was easily persuaded by Hideyoshi Hashiba, the eventual ruler of Japan. This was the destiny of lord of the border castle.

The portrait of Nobunaga Oda, attributed to Soshu Kano, owned by Chokoji Temple, in the late 16th century (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The Portrait of Hideyoshi Toyotomi, attributed to Mitsunobu Kano, owned by Kodaiji Temple (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Harsh Fate of Hidemura Hiri, Lord of Castle

Since Hidemura formed an allegiance with Hideyoshi, the Azai Clan were eventually beaten. Furthermore, Hideyoshi assisted Hidemura defend Kamaha Castle from an Azai Clan attack in 1571. This resulted in Nobunaga, Hidemura and Hideyoshi capturing Odani Castle (the home base of the Azai Clan) in 1573. A year later (in 1574) shortly after the succession, Hidemura was fired by Nobunaga due to Hidemura’s senior vassal’s failures. The primary reason for this is still unknown, but perhaps we can assume that this was purely the cruelty of Nobunaga’s character. Some historians speculate that there was a power imbalance since Hidemura was getting more powerful through his allegiance with Nobunaga. It was well-known that Hidemura accumulated more territory than Hideyoshi, who at the time was Nobunaga’s important retainer. Nobunaga might have the rebellion by Hidemura, or perhaps he wanted to take the territory for him. As the famous Chinese proverb goes “When the nimble rabbit dies, the hunting dog will be cooked”, so too was the fate of Hidemura. Finally, there is a strong belief by historians that Hidemura was hired by Hideyoshi and his brother Hidenaga in the end.

The ruins of Odani Castle
The portrait of Hidenaga Toyotomi, owned by Shungakuin Temple (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Systems of Castle improved uniquely

Kamaha Castle was finally abandoned in 1575. Some historians assumed that because the castle was made of soil, and that it was inferior to other castles, that it was abandoned sooner than other castles. However, according to a more recent excavation, it was revealed that Kamaha Castle actually had an advance system compared to other mountain castles. Kamaha Castle had at least a 3-level large turret, like a Main Tower, in the northern enclosures of the castle. This turret was thought to be used by defenders who shot arrows against attackers, as well as a large ditch located in front of it. If attackers had the misfortune of getting stuck in the ditch, it would give a clear and perfect sight for the defenders. Many enclosures were surrounded by stone walls. Moreover, the main enclosure at the center of the castle had its entrance with a square space surrounded by stone walls and steps called “Koguchi”. These types of systems were seldom seen in castles that were built after Azuchi Castle which Nobunaba built back in 1579. Based on these findings, Kamaha Castle was truly more advance than Azuchi Castle.

The imaginary drawing of the large turret of Kamaha Castle, quoted from the Kamaha Castle Official Site
The imaginary drawing of Azuchi Castle, exhibited by Gifu Castle Museum

On the other hand, there were some differences between Kamaha Castle and Azuchi Castle as well. The large turret in Kamaha Castle was placed on earthen walls, and not on stone walls. These stone walls supported the earthen walls which prevented them from collapsing. In the case of Azuchi Castle, its main tower was built on stone walls directly. The Koguchi entrance of Kamaha Castle was designed for the gate of the main hall, and not for defense. Koguchi entrances built after Azuchi Castle exhibited more defensive capabilities, combined with complex routes. Historian often speculate that the systems used in Kamaha Castle had been improved uniquely, but was eventually replaced with other systems which were first seen in Azuchi Castle. However, the design of Kamaha Castle ‘s large turret might have been used for the main towers of other castles. This is because Hideoyoshi who would eventually build Osaka Castle included its main tower, must have seen the large turret when he worked with Hidemura at Kamaha Castle.

The stone walls of Kamaha Castle
The stone wall base for the Main Tower of Azuchi Castle
Koguchi entrance ruins of Kamaha Castle
The Kocuchi entrance of the Kurogane-mon Gate of Azuchi Castle

To be continued in “Kamaha Castle Part2”

156.鎌刃城 その1

先進的なシステムを持った山城

立地と歴史

近江国南北の境目の城

鎌刃城は、近江国(現在の滋賀県に当たります)にあった戦国時代の山城です。この城はこの国の中央部分にありましたが、当時この国は北部と南部に分けられていました。その結果、二つの戦国大名、南側は六角氏が、北側は浅井氏がこの国を治めていて、この城は双方から奪ったり奪われたりしていました。鎌刃城は、霊仙(りょうぜん)山の峰の一つ(標高384m)に築かれました。城の名の「鎌刃」は、両側が急崖になっているその峰の形から由来しています。この城は主要街道の一つ、中山道の近くにあり、戦の際にも移動する際にも便利な位置にありました。

近江国の範囲と鎌刃城の位置

城周辺の起伏地図

戦国時代の16世紀中盤、堀氏がこの城の城主でした。堀氏は、状況に応じてその主君を度々変えていました。一例として1553年に六角氏が鎌刃城を攻めたとき、堀氏は一旦逃亡して、結局は六角氏に降伏しその配下となりました。ところが、浅井氏が勢力を広げていると見ると浅井氏と同盟を結ぶことにしたのです。そして1570年に浅井氏が織田信長と戦ったときには、その当時の当主であった堀秀村は、信長の部下でその後天下人、豊臣秀吉となる羽柴秀吉の説得により、今度は信長の味方となりました。これは、境目の城の城主としての運命だったのかもしれません。

織田信長肖像画、狩野宗秀作、長興寺蔵、16世紀後半 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
豊臣秀吉肖像画、加納光信筆、高台寺蔵 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

城主、堀秀村の過酷な運命

秀村が秀吉との共闘を始めてから、浅井氏は最後には滅亡しました。それだけでなく、1571年に鎌刃城が浅井氏に攻められたときには、秀吉は城を守る秀村を助けたりしました。そして、1573年には信長、秀吉、秀村は小谷城(浅井氏の本拠地)を攻め落としたのです。ところが、その成功のわずか1年後の1574年、秀村は家臣の落ち度により、信長から改易されてしまいます。改易の本当の理由については、今でもわかっていません。しかし、信長の苛烈な性格から来ていることは想像できます。歴史家の中には、パワーバランスの不均衡を指摘する人もいます。すなわち、秀村は信長との同盟により増々力をつけていました。そして、当時信長の重要な部下であった秀吉よりも領土を広げていました。信長は秀村による反乱を恐れたかもしれず、単に秀村から領地を取り上げたかったのかもしれません。中国のことわざ「狡兎(こうと)死 しして走狗(そうく)烹(に)らる」に言われているような、秀村にとっては過酷な運命でした。歴史家によれば、最後には秀村は秀吉や秀吉の弟、秀長に仕えたようです。

小谷城跡
豊臣秀長肖像画、春岳院蔵 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

独自に発展した鎌刃城のシステム

鎌刃城は、1575年についに廃城となりました。歴史家は、この城は土造りで(後の時代の)他の城より劣っているのではないかと考えていました。早い時期に廃城となったからです。ところが、最新の発掘の成果によると、鎌刃城は実際には、他の山城に比べてずっと進んだシステムを備えていたことが判明したのです。鎌刃城の北の曲輪群のところには、天守のような、少なくとも三重の大櫓があったのです。この櫓は、守備兵が攻撃してくる兵に対して矢を放つために使われたと考えられています。また、その前面には大堀切があり、攻撃兵がそこに釘付けになれば、櫓の守備兵からはちょうど標的になるようになっていました。多くの曲輪は石垣によって囲まれていました。更に、城の中心部分の主郭には「虎口」と呼ばれる、石垣や石段に囲まれた四角いスペースがある入口がありました。このような形式のシステムに似たものとして、1579年に信長が築いた安土城などが挙げられます。これらの発見を目の当たりにすると、鎌刃城は安土城よりかなり先駆けていたのではないかと思ってしまいます。

鎌刃城大櫓の想像図、鎌刃城公式サイトより引用
安土城想像図、岐阜城展示室より

一方で、鎌刃城と安土城の間には、いくつか違うところもあります。鎌刃城の大櫓は土塁の上に据えられていて、石垣の上には建っていません。ここの石垣は、崩壊を防ぐために土塁を支えているだけです。安土城の場合は、その天守は石垣の上に直接乗っていました。鎌刃城の虎口は、御殿の門として作られていて防御のためではありません。安土城以後の虎口は、複雑な通路と組み合わされて、防衛のための能力を持っていました。歴史家は、鎌刃城で使われたシステムは独自に発展したが、そのうちに安土城から始まる別のシステムに置き換えられたしまったと考えています。それでも、鎌刃城の大櫓のデザインは、その後他の城に築かれる天守に影響したかもしれません。それは、後に天守を含む大坂城を築くことになる秀吉が、鎌刃城の秀村と一緒に働いたときに、きっとこの大櫓を見ていたはずだからです。

鎌刃城の石垣
安土城の天守台石垣
鎌刃城の虎口
安土城黒金門の虎口

「鎌刃城その2」に続きます。

50.Hikone Castle Part3

I admire the great efforts of Hikone City.

Features

Western Enclosure, Guardian of Back Side

There are many other attractions in this castle. For example, there is the Western Enclosure in the back of the Main Enclosure. It has the remaining Western Enclosure Three-level Turret to protect the back side of the castle. There is also another large, deep ditch with a bridge over it in front of the turret like the front side. This castle was protected strictly on both sides.

The aerial photo around the castle

The Western Enclosure Three-level Turret
The Large Ditch in front of the turret
The bridge over the ditch
The interior of the third floor of the turret
A view from the third floor

Extensive Original Front Side

Also consider walking around the southwest part of the castle, on the opposite of the front entrance. You will see there is still a large area surrounded by the Middle Moat and the Inner Moat. It is very comfortable to walk along the moats looking up the Main Tower. You will see the Kyobashi-guchi-mon Gate Ruins behind the Middle Moat, the Main Gate Ruins behind the Inner Moat and so on. You can also see this area had originally been the front side of the castle against the Toyotomi Clan at Osaka Castle in this direction.

The Kyobashi-guchi-mon Gate Ruins
The area surrounded by the Middle Moat and the Inner Moat
The Main Gate Ruins
The Funamachi-guchi-mon Gate Ruins, the other route over the Middle Moat
A distant view of the Western Enclosure Three-level Turret from around the Middle Moat
A distant view of the Main Tower from around the Middle Moat

Later History

After the Meiji Restoration, Hikone Castle was under the Japanese Army to be sold. When the Emperor Meiji visited Hikone in 1878, he felt sorry about the lost of the castle and ordered to preserve it. The castle was owned by the Imperial Household, followed by the Ii Clan and now Hikone City. In 1945 during World War II, the US Army was planning an air raid to Hikone in the evening, on August 15th just after the Emperor Showa declared the end of the war. The castle might have been saved by the emperors twice. Hikone City is trying to register the castle on the World Heritage List.

The illuminated Hikone Castle
The Large Ditch in front of the Balance Turret
The Main Tower at the Main Enclosure
The Genkyuen, the garden for the lord at the castle site

My Impression

When I visited Hikone Castle, I was very pleased to enter not only the Main Tower, but also most of the remaining turrets. It is very rare compare to other castles. I asked an officer why they allow some visitors to enter these turrets. His answer was that because they stored all of the items in the castle buildings into the Hikone Castle Museum. I understood it and was impressed by the great efforts of the city for preserving and continuing the castle into future generations.

The Balance Turret
The interior of the Balance Turret
The entrance of the Drum Gate Turret
The Western Enclosure Three-level Turret
The interior of Western Enclosure Three-level Turret
A view of the Hikone Castle Museum from the Main Enclosure

How to get There

If you want to visit the castle by car, it is about 10 minutes away from Hikone IC on the Meshin Expressway. There are several parking lots in the castle site.
By public transportation, it takes about 15 minutes on foot from the JR Hikone Station.
To get to Hikone Station from Tokyo: Take the Tokaido Shinkansen super express and transfer to the Biwako Line at Maibara Station or Kyoto Station.

The parking lot next to the Stable

Links and References

Hikone Castle, Visit Omi

That’s all. Thank you.
Back to “Hikone Castle Part1”
Back to “Hikone Castle Part2”