162.Izushi Castle/Arikoyama Castle Part1

The Izushi area is known as its old castle town where many people visit to enjoy walking, eating and shopping around the area including the Izushi Castle Ruins at the foot of the mountain. If you look up at the mountain on a fine day, you will find stone walls on the top, which are other castle ruins in this area, called Arikoyama Castle which had been built before Izushi Castle.

Location and History

Two Castle Ruins in Izushi Area

Izushi Castle is located in modern day in the Izushi area of Toyooka City in the northern part of Hyogo Prefecture. The area is known as the old castle town where many people visit to enjoy walking, eating and shopping around the area including the Izushi Castle Ruins at the foot of the mountain. If you look up at the mountain on a fine day, you will find stone walls on the top, which are other castle ruins in this area, called Arikoyama Castle which had been built before Izushi Castle. These things make you understand the area has a very long history and rich culture.

The range of Toyooka City and the location of the castles

A street of the old Izushi castle town
Izushi Castle Ruins in the front and Arikoyama Castle Ruins in the back
The zooemed stone walls on the mountain

Yamana Clan, One of Greatest Lords during Middle Ages

Arikoyama Castle was first built by the Yamana Clan which is known as one of the greatest lords during the Middle Ages. The clan was a branch family of the Nitta Clan, which came from the Kanto Region in eastern Japan. When the Ashikaga Shogunate was established, Tokiuji Yamana, who was the lord of the clan at that time, greatly supported Takauji Ashikaga, the founder of the shogunate. That’s why Takauji sent Tokiuji to the Sanin area, the northern part of the Chugoku Region to govern, where their enemies were still active. Tokiuji and his descendants conquered their territories by force and finally became the governors of 11 out of 66 provinces in Japan, called Rokubun-no-ichi-dono (meaning the Lord of One Sixth of Japan).

The family crest of the Yamana Clan (licensed by Houunji 1642 via Wikimedia Commons)
The 11 provinces the Yamana Clan became governors (the colored ones)  (licensed by ja:User:味っ子 via Wikimedia Commons)

However, Yoshimitsu Ashikaga, the third Shogun, was afraid of the overwhelming power of the Yamana Clan and defeated it in 1391, known as the Meitoku Rebellion. The clan’s power once declined but Sozen Yamana came out in the 15th Century and revived it as they had been. He is known as the commander in chief of the Western Alliance against the Eastern Alliance led by Katsumoto Hosokawa during the Onin War between 1467 and 1477 which would start the Sengoku Period. The clan eventually had many provinces again and its home was in the current Izushi area of Tajima Province which is now known as northern Hyogo Prefecture. The lords of the clan were first based in Konosumi-yama Castle on a mountain, about 5km north of the later Arikoyama Castle. Sozen actually made a sally with about 26 thousand warriors from this castle to fight with the Eastern Alliance in Kyoto.

The portrait of Sozen Yamana, from “Honcho-Hyakushoden” (licensed by Musuketeer.3 via Wikimedia Commons)
The portrait of Katsumoto Hosokawa, owned by Ryoanji Temple  (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Unlike the Hosokawa Clan which had a certain position in the central government, the Yamana Clan had to maintain its provinces by force. It got difficult for the clan to do it during the Sengoku Period when overthrowing their lords were often seen as overthrowing the whole country. The clan eventually lost its provinces one by one, being defeated in many battles against other warlords like the Akamatsu and Amago Clans. As a result, the Yamana’s authority decreased and some of its senior vassals tried to become independent. Suketoyo Yamana, the lord of the clan tried to somehow manage to maintain his last Tajima Province by building Takeda Castle near the border to other provinces, and asking greater warlords like the Oda and Mori Clans for help.

The range of Tajima Province and the location of the castles

The ruins of Takeda Castle

Suketoyo Yamana moves his home to Arikoyama Castle

However, when the Oda Clan attacked the Tajima Province in 1569, Suketomo’s home Konosumi-yama Castle was captured and he had to escape from the place. This might have been caused by the secret agreement between the Oda and Mori Clans that the Tajima Province would belong to the Oda. Suketoyo somehow returned to his territory in 1570 after he had met with Nobunaga Oda (the lord of the clan) while paying lots of money from mining in the province. Then, he moved to his home to Arikoyama Castle, located on a much higher and steeper mountain than Konosumi-yama Castle, and improved it so that the fall of his castle would never happen again. Suketomo usually lived in the residence at the foot of the mountain, which would be the origin of Izushi Castle and its castle town.

The portrait of Nobunaga Oda, attributed to Soshu Kano, owned by Chokoji Temple, in the late 16th century (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

The relief map around the castles

In the 1570’s, the Oda and Mori Clans began to oppose each other. Suketomo was debating on the face on which side he would support. The Oda Clan attacked the Tajima Province again in 1580 by sending Hidenaga Hashiba who was the little brother of Hideyoshi, the later ruler of Japan. It is said that one of the reasons for the invasion was that they wanted to own the mines in the province, such as the Ikuno Silver Mine. Hidenaga’s troops surrounded Arikoyama Castle and Suketomo finally had to surrender perhaps because they had no hope for reinforcements.

The portrait of Hidenaga Hashiba, owned by Shungakuin Temple (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Hidenaga Hashiba improves Castle

After that, Hidenaga lived in and improved the castle as the home base of the Tajima Province. The castle had been made of soil so far but its main portion on the top was fortified by building stone walls. It is said that Takatora Todo, who was a senior vassal of Hidenaga and would later become a master of castle constructions, built them. Senjoshiki (meaning the 1,000 mat enclosure), next to the main portion, was developed to accommodate many soldiers and supplies even when other lords in the province gathered for help.

The portrait of Takatora Todo, private owned (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The imaginary drawing of Arikoyama Castle, exhibited by Karo Yashiki Residence

Yoshihide Koide builds Izushi Castle

The castle was followed by the Koide Clan, a relative of Hideyoshi Toyotomi after he became the ruler of Japan. The clan somehow survived when the ruler was changed from the Toyotomi Clan to the Tokugawa Shogunate. In 1604, Yoshihide Koide renovated the foot residence and renamed it Izushi Castle perhaps due to the convenience for the government. He also abandoned Arikoyama Castle on the mountain instead. The new castle and its castle town prospered during the Edo Period as the Izushi Domain, which was finally followed by the Sengoku Clan until the end of the period.

The imaginary drawing of Izushi Castle, exhibited by Karo Yashiki Residence

To be continued in “Izushi Castle/Arikoyama Castle Part2”

162.出石城・有子山城 その1

出石は古い城下町を残していることで知られていて、多くの観光客が訪れ、山の麓にある出石城跡を含むエリアでの散策、食事、買い物などを楽しんでいます。晴れた日にその山を見上げてみると、その頂上には石垣があるのがわかります。それがもう一つのこの地区にある城跡で、出石城の前に築かれた有子山城です。

立地と歴史

出石にある2つの城跡

出石城は、現在の兵庫県北部にある豊岡市の出石地区にありました。出石は古い城下町を残していることで知られていて、多くの観光客が訪れ、山の麓にある出石城跡を含むエリアでの散策、食事、買い物などを楽しんでいます。晴れた日にその山を見上げてみると、その頂上には石垣があるのがわかります。それがもう一つのこの地区にある城跡で、出石城の前に築かれた有子山城です。このような城跡群があることで、この地区には長い歴史があり、豊かな文化が育まれたことがわかります。

豊岡市の範囲と城の位置

出石の街並み
手前が出石城跡、背後が有子山城跡
山上の石垣をズームアップ

日本有数の守護大名、山名氏

有子山城は、中世の時代に最も有力な守護大名の一つであった山名氏によって築かれました。山名氏は新田氏の支族で、東日本の関東地方の出身です。足利幕府が設立される頃、その当時の当主であった山名時氏が、初代将軍の足利尊氏の幕府創業に大いに貢献しました。そのため尊氏は、まだ敵方(南朝)の活動が活発であった中国地方の北部、山陰地域の平定のために時氏を送り込んだのです。時氏とその後継者たちは武力をもってその地域を征服し、ついには日本で66ある国のうち、11までの国の守護になりました。よって、山名氏は「六分の一殿」と称されるに至りました。

山名氏の家紋、五七桐に七葉根笹  (licensed by Houunji 1642 via Wikimedia Commons)
山名氏が守護となった11ヶ国  (licensed by ja:User:味っ子 via Wikimedia Commons)

ところが、3代将軍の義満は山名氏の勢力が過度に大きくなることを恐れ、1391年の明徳の乱と呼ばれる戦いにより山名氏を征伐しました。山名氏の勢力は一時衰えますが、15世紀になると山名宗全が現れ、かつてのような勢力を回復します。1467年から1477年の間に戦われ、戦国時代の幕開けとなった応仁の乱において、細川勝元率いる東軍に対抗して、宗全は西軍の総大将を務めました。山名氏は再び多くの国の守護となり、現在の兵庫県北部にあたる但馬国の出石地区を本拠地としました。山名氏の当主は最初は、後の有子山城から約5km北にある此隅山城(このすみやまじょう)を居城としていて、宗全はこの城から2万6千人の軍勢を率いて出陣し、京都で東軍と戦ったのです。

山名宗全肖像画、「本朝百将伝」より  (licensed by Musuketeer.3 via Wikimedia Commons)
細川勝元肖像画、龍安寺蔵 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

中央政府で確固たる地位を築いていた細川氏と違い、山名氏は自国の領土を武力によって維持する必要がありました。しかし、戦国時代になって下剋上が国中に広まっている中で、それが難しくなっていったのです。山名氏はやがて、赤松氏や尼子氏などの他の戦国大名との数々の戦いに敗れ、領地の国を一つずつ失っていきました。その結果、山名の権威は失墜し、その重臣たちまでもが独立を志向しました。山名氏の当主であった山名祐豊(やまなすけとよ)は、何とか最後の但馬国だけは維持しようと、他の国との国境近くに竹田城を築いたりしました。そしてより強大な戦国大名である織田氏や毛利氏に助けを求めようとしました。

但馬国の範囲と城の位置

竹田城跡

山名祐豊が本拠地を有子山城に移転

ところが、1569年に織田氏は但馬国を攻撃します。祐豊の本拠地、此隅山城は落城し、祐豊はそこから逃亡せざるを得ませんでした。このことの背景に、但馬国を織田の勢力圏とするという、織田氏・毛利氏間の密約があったのではないかと言われています。祐豊は、織田信長に会い、但馬国の鉱山からの収益から多額の献金をすることで、1570年に帰還することが叶いました。そして彼はその本拠地を、此隅山城よりずっと高く険しい山にある有子山城に移し、二度と落城することがないよう改修しました。祐豊は普段は山麓にある屋敷に住んでいて、それが出石城とその城下町の起源となります。

織田信長肖像画、狩野宗秀作、長興寺蔵、16世紀後半 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

城周辺の起伏地図

1570年代になると、織田氏と毛利氏は対立するようになります。祐豊は、どちらの側に付いてよいのか逡巡します。そうするうちに織田氏は1580年に但馬国を再び攻撃しました。後に天下人となる羽柴秀吉の弟、羽柴秀長を派遣したのです。その侵攻の理由の一つとして、生野銀山などの但馬国の鉱山を手に入れたかったのではないかと言われています。秀長の軍勢は有子山城を包囲し、恐らくは援軍の望みがなくたったことで、祐豊はついに降伏しました。

豊臣秀長肖像画、春岳院蔵 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

羽柴秀長が有子山城を改修

その後、秀長は有子山城に居座り、但馬国の本拠地として城を改修しました。それまでこの城は土造りでしたが、山頂にある城の主要部分は、石垣を築くことで強化されました。後に築城の名手と称されるようになる秀長の重臣、藤堂高虎が携わったと言われています。主要部のとなりの千畳敷曲輪は、国中の領主たちが援軍として集結しても十分兵員や物資を収容できるよう拡張されました。

藤堂高虎肖像画、個人蔵 (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
有子山城の想像図、出石「家老屋敷」にて展示

小出吉英が出石城を築城

城はそれから、豊臣秀吉が天下人となった後、その親族である小出氏に引き継がれました。小出氏は、天下の権が豊臣氏から徳川幕府に移ってもなんとか生き残りました。1604年に小出吉英(こいでよしひで)が山麓の屋敷を大改修し、出石城としました。恐らく統治の利便のためだったでしょう。そして、代わりに山上の有子山城を廃城としました。山麓の新しい城とその城下町は、出石藩として江戸時代の間繁栄しました。その後、仙石氏が藩主となり、江戸時代末まで統治しました。

出石城の想像図、出石「家老屋敷」にて展示

「出石城・有子山城その2」に続きます。

60.Ako Castle Part3

According to Historians, The 47 Ronin assaulted Kira due to their Samurai Spirit. If it’s true, why is the story still so popular among many current Japanese people?

Features

Many Attractions in Main Enclosure

The Main Enclosure is compact and all surrounded by stone walls and water moats, so you can easily see its complex layout. There are three entrances to it but only two of them are available excluding Hanebashi-mon (meaning Draw Bridge Gate) in the back of the southern side.

The aerial photo around the Main Enclosure of the castle, the red markers indicates its three entrances

The stone walls and water moats of the Main Enclosure
The ruins of the Draw Bridge Gate

The front gate of the northern side was restored and has the Masugata system as well.

The front gate
The inside of the Masugata system

The other one of the eastern side, called Umaya-guchi-mon (meaning Stable Side Gate), was also restored. The gate was simple but the stone walls around are bent elaborately to protect the gate from guns and arrows from the walls.

The front side of the Stable Side Gate
The back side of the Stable Side Gate

There was the Main Hall inside where the lords including Asano (Takumi-no-kami) lived. Now, there is a flat exhibition of the hall instead, where you can see its layout and what rooms were in it.

The layout of the Main Hall drawn in the illustration during the Edo Period, from the signboard at the site
the flat exhibition of the layout

The large stone wall base for a Main Tower stands out at its corner and you can climb it and see the view of the area around from the top.

The Main Tower base
A view from the top of the base

There is also a small but beautiful pond garden which is designated as a National Place of Scenic Beauty, together with that of the Second Enclosure.

The pond garden

Later History

After the Meiji Restoration, Ako Castle was abandoned and all the castle buildings were sold or demolished. Most of the moats were buried and turned into fields and residences area with other castle’s land. The Main Enclosure was used as a school until 1981. The Oishi Shrine was established in 1912. The restoration of the castle started in 1935 where the moats in front of the Main Enclosure were re-dug. Since then, many other buildings and structures of the castle have been restored probably because of the popularity of the incident and Ronin. The ruins have been designated as a National Historic Site since 1971.

The old photo of the Main Enclosure front gate, from the signboard at the site
The old photo of the Second Enclosure gate, from the signboard at the site
The ruins of Ako Castle in the 1930’s  (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

My Impression

I honestly say I don’t like the Ako Incident story because there was no good reason for killing Kira (in addition, in the very popular play “Chushin-gura” based on this incident, Asano cuts Kira at the front (in fact, it was from the back) after Kira’s bullying due to Asano refusing the huge bribe or Asano’s wife refusing Kira’s love). Historians say this was done due to Bushi-do (the Samurai Spirit) which refers to their devotion to their master or domain with honor and pride even without any reasons. If it’s true, why is the story still so popular among many current Japanese people? I guess it’s because they still have the same or similar devotion to Samurai in the Edo Period as they sometimes look devoted to their boss or company without any reasons to survive. I also speculate that Oishi might have understood his master was mad but he didn’t have any other choice.

A Ukiyoe-painting of Asano assaulting Kira in the Edo Castle, attributed to Kuniteru Utagawa (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

How to get There

If you want to visit there by car, it is about a 10 minutes’ drive away from Ako IC on the Sanyo Expressway. There are several parking lots around the castle ruins.
By public transportation, it takes about 15 minutes on foot to get there from JR Banshu-Ako Station.
From Tokyo or Osaka to the station: Take the Sanyo Shinkansen super express express and transfer to the Sanyo Line at Himeji Station or the Ako Line at Aiou Station.

Banshu-Ako Station

That’s all. Thank you.
Back to “AKo Castle Part1”
Back to “Ako Castle Part2”