The mountain and ruins protected by the Tokugawa Clan
Later History
After the battle in 1584, Komakiyama Castle was abandoned again. In the beginning of the Edo Period, parts of the huge stones were taken away for the construction of Nagoya Castle. You can see one stone which was divided but was not used in the construction. During the Edo Period, the Tokugawa Clan banned people from entering Mt. Komakiyama, because the place was the site of the ruins of their founder Ieyasu’s victory and fortune. For many years during the Modern Times, the mountain was privately owned by the Tokugawa Clan. It is said that it made the foundation of the castle very durable. The ruins were designated as a National Historic Site in 1927 after the Tokugawa Clan donated the mountain to the nation.
My Impression
It was believed previously, that Komakiyama Castle was just a temporary position for Nobunaga to plan his next step. However, the achievement of the recent excavation made people change their ideas about the castle. I was actually surprised to see the remains of the huge stones and learned they came from Nobunaga’s ideas about castle building. I am looking forward to seeing new discoveries and studies in the future.
How to get There
If you want to visit there by car: It is about 10 minutes away from Komaki IC on Tomei Expressway. There are several parking lots around the mountain including the Komaki City Hall. By train, it takes about 30 minutes on foot from Komaki Station on Meitetsu Komaki Line. To get to Komaki Station from Tokyo or Osaka: Take the Tokaido Shinkansen Super Express, get off at Nagoya Station, transfer to the Higashiyama Subway Line, transfer at Sakae Station to the Meijo Subway Line, and transfer at Heandori Station to Meitetsu Komaki Line.
中世と近世が同居している城
A castle mixed with the Middle Ages and the Modern times
立地と歴史~Location and History
武田信玄の本陣~Stronghold for Shingen Takeda
長野県長野市にある松代城は、真田氏の城下町として有名な観光地です。この城には長い歴史があります。16世紀に武田氏が最初に築城し、その頃は海津城と呼ばれていました。この城の建設の理由は、近くの川中島が越後国(現在の新潟県)の上杉氏との最前線であったからです。城は北側が千曲川に接していて、土塁や水堀に囲まれていました。また、城の門の外側には馬出しという武田氏独特の防御システムが備えられていました。城は実際に、1561年の非常に有名な上杉謙信との川中島の戦いにおいて武田信玄の本陣として使われました。 Matsusshiro Castle is a famous attraction in Nagano City, Nagano Prefecture, which was known as a Sanada Clan castle town. The castle has a long history. It was first built by the Takeda Clan in the late 16th Century and was called Kaizu Castle. The reason for the construction was that the area nearby called Kawanakajima was the front line against the Uesugi Clan in Echigo Province (what is now Niigata Prefecture). The castle bordered Chikuma-gawa River on the north and was surrounded by earthen walls and water moats. It is also said that it was equipped with the Takeda Clan’s unique defense system called Umadashi outside the castle gates. The castle was actually used as the stronghold for Shingen Takeda when he fought with Kenshin Uesugi in the very famous fourth Battle of Kawanakajima in 1561.
城の位置~The location of the castle
真田氏による統治~Governance by Sanada Clan
1582年に武田氏が織田氏により滅ぼされた後は、この城の城主は何度も変わりました。最終的には真田氏が、城と城下町を含む松代藩を1622年から江戸時代末まで支配しました。また、1711年には徳川幕府により、城の名前が松代城と変更されました。城はそれまでに改修が続けられます。例えば、城の中心地である本丸は、内堀とともに石垣によって囲まれました。石垣の四隅の上には4基の櫓が築かれ、3基の門が本丸の入口に設置されました。本丸の内部には御殿があり、城主が住んでいました。一方、外堀とともに本丸と内堀を囲む二の丸は、まだ土塁があるだけでした。また、恐らくは武田時代に由来する馬出しも残っていました。 After the Takeda Clan was defeated by the Oda Clan in 1582, the lords of the castle were changed several times. The Sanada Clan finally governed the Matsushiro Domain including the castle and the castle town from 1622 until the end of the Edo Period. The castle was also renamed Matsushiro Castle by the Tokugawa Shogunate in 1711. The castle continued to be improved until then. For example, the center of the castle called the Main Enclosure was surrounded by stone walls with the Inner Moat. Four turrets were built on the four corners of the stone walls, and three gates were set at the entrances of the enclosure. The Main Hall was inside of the enclosure where the lord lived. On the other hand, the Second Enclosure with the Outer Moat surrounding the Main Enclosure and InnerMoat still had the earthen walls. The Umadashi system which probably originated in Takeda’s period, also remained.
新しい御殿~New Main Halls
しかしながら、この城の川に近い立地は防御には有利でしたが、統治や居住には不利でした。城は洪水の被害に何度も見舞われました。火災による被害もあり、真田氏は居宅を城の中心地から南西部分に移すことを決め、花の丸御殿を建設します。江戸時代末には城から離れた地に、親族関係者(婦女子)のための新御殿も建てました。 However, this castle’s location near the river was positive for defense, but negative for governance and living. The castle suffered damage from floods several times. It was also damaged by fires, so the Samada Clan decided to escape their home from the center of the castle to the southwest part, building Hananomaru Main Hall. The clan also built the New Main Hall for their relatives (women and children) far from the castle at the end of the Edo Period.
特徴~Features
江戸時代末期のように復元~Restored like End of Edo Period
現在、松代城の中心部は以前の姿に似通って見えます。本丸の石垣のみが現存しているのですが、本丸の2つの門、内堀と2つの橋、そして二の丸を囲む土塁さえもが長野市によって復元されています。市の関係者によると、江戸時代末期の姿を再現したということです。 Now, the center of Matsushiro Castle looks similar to its former appearance. Only the stone walls of the Main Enclosure are original, but two gates to the Main Enclosure, the Inner Moat with two bridges, and even earthen walls surrounding the Second Enclosure have been restored by Nagano City. The city officials say they tried to restore the castle to show its appearance at the end of the Edo Period.
城周辺の航空写真~The aerial photo around the castle
対照的な二の丸と本丸~Contrastive Second and Main Enclosures
観光客は通常、二の丸の入口である南門跡から城に入っていきます。この門跡は、復元された土塁に囲まれていて、その近くには馬出しの痕跡がわずかに残っています。この土塁と本丸の石垣はとても対照的です。それぞれが元々は別の時代に作られたからです。土塁は中世の戦国時代に由来し、石垣は主に江戸時代に作られました。 Visitors usually enter the castle through the ruins of the South Gate, the entrance of the Second Enclosure. The ruins are surrounded by the restored earthen walls and the trace of the Umadashi system slightly remains nearby. The earthen walls and the stone walls of the Main Enclosure are very contrastive because both of them come from different periods. The earthen walls are from the Sengoku Period of the Middle Ages and the stone walls are mainly from the Edo Period of the Modern Times.
本丸へは内堀にかかっている橋を渡り、太鼓門を通って入ります。これらは皆復元されたもので、城の新しいシンボルになりました。本丸の内側は1717年の大火以降は空き地になっています。角にあった4つの櫓は復元されていませんが、石垣は残っています。北西角のものは一番大きく、櫓の以前には天守が立っていたのではないかと言われています。また、この櫓の石垣とその積み方は他のものよりは古風であり、とても荒々しく見えます。櫓台の上に階段で登り、城周りの景色を見ることができます。 You can enter the Main Enclosure through the Taiko-mon Gate after crossing the bridge over the Inner Moat. These structures have all been restored and have become new symbols of the castle. The inside of the Main Enclosure has remained empty since the great fire in 1717. The four turrets on the corners have not been restored, but their stone wall bases remain. The northwest one is the largest and it is said that the Main Tower might have stood on it before the turret. Its stone walls and the method for piling them are also older than other stone walls, so they look very rough. You can go up the stairs to the top of the base to see a view around the castle.
独特な構造~Unique Structures
本丸の北側にはもう一つの復元された北不明門があります。その門をくぐっていくと、本丸を囲んでいる二の丸に戻っていきます。二の丸の北外側は、かつては千曲川でした。江戸時代に洪水を防ぐため、川の流路が替えられたのです。面白いものとしては、埋門という復元された小さな門が二の丸の土塁の所にあります。土塁に通した穴の中に組み込まれていますが、戦が始まったときには埋められるようになってました。 The northern side of the Main Enclosure has another restored gate called Kita-Akazu-mon. You can go through the gate back to the Second Enclosure surrounding the Main Enclosure. The outside of the Second Enclosure on the north was the Chikumagawa-River in the past. The route of the river was changed in the Edo Period to prevent floods. There is an interesting small, restored gate called Uzumi-mon in the earthen walls of the Second Enclosure. It was originally set in a hole through the walls which would have been filled when a battle happened.
その後~Later History
明治維新後、松代城は廃城となり、ほとんどの建物は売られるか撤去され、ほとんどの土地は元藩士に分け与えられ農地となりました。1904年、元藩主であり新御殿に住んでいた真田家は土地の一部を買い戻し、城跡を公園として公開しました。最終的には1951年にその土地を公共のものとして寄付しました。1981年には城跡は国の史跡に指定されましたが、当時は城の中心部に石垣だけが残っている状態でした。長野市は城跡を調査しいくつかの門、橋、土塁、水堀の復元を開始します。その復元は2004年に完了し、現在私たちは城が過去どのような姿であったか目にすることができるのです。 After the Meiji Restoration, Matsushiro Castle was abandoned, most of its buildings were sold or demolished, and most of its land was divided by former warriors to be turned into farm. In 1904, the former lord of the castle, the Sanada Clan, living in the New Main Hall, bought part of the land back to open the ruins of the castle as a park. The clan lastly donated the land to the officials in 1951. The ruins of the castle were designated as a National Historic Site in 1981, but only the stone walls remained at the center of the castle at that time. Nagano City investigated the ruins and started to restore some of gates, bridges, earthen walls and water moats. The restoration was completed in 2004 and we can now see what the castle looked like in the past.
私の感想~My Impression
松代城には、異なる時代の異なる特徴が同居しており、独特の雰囲気があると思います。石垣と土塁の面白い組み合わせを見ることができるからです。加えて、城から250m南にある真田邸をご覧になることをお勧めします。真田邸は実は新御殿の現在の名前なのです。城に関連する数少ない現存建物の一つです。これもまた国の史跡となっています。もともと藩主の近親者のために作られたものなので、その内装はとても優雅です。 I think that Matsushiro Castle has a unique atmosphere because it has different perspectives from different periods. You can see the interesting combination of its stone walls and earthen walls. In addition, I recommend that you visit the Sanada Hall, about 250m south of the castle. In fact, Sanada Hall is the present name of the New Main Hall, one of the few remaining buildings that form part of the castle. It is also designated as a National Historic Site. Its interior is very elegant as it was first built for the lord’s relatives.
ここに行くには~How to get There
上信越自動車道の長野ICから約5分のところです。城の周りにいくつか駐車場があります。 公共交通機関を使う場合は、長野駅からバスに乗り、松代駅バス停で降りてください。 It takes about 5 minutes from Nagano IC on Joshinetsu Expressway. There are parking lots around the castle. If you want to go there by public transportation, take the bus from Nanano Station and get off at the Matsushiro-eki bus stop.
リンク、参考情報~Links and References
・松代城の環境整備、長野市(Nagano City Official Website) ・よみがえる日本の城14、学研(Japanese Book) ・「日本の城改訂版第7号」デアゴスティーニジャパン(Japanese Book)
加賀藩100万石の領主、前田家の城
The castle for the Maeda Clan, the lord of the Kaga Domain with one million koku of rice
立地と歴史~Location and History
寺院から城へ~Changing from Temple to Castle
金沢城は、石川県金沢市の最も有名なシンボルの一つであり続けています。城は、金沢平野に突き出した小立野大地の端に位置しており、犀川と浅野川に挟まれています。この地には最初、戦国時代の16世紀、大坂城の前身と同じように、一向宗の信者が住む尾山御坊がありました。加賀国(現在の石川県)は当時「百姓の持ちたる国」と呼ばれ、御坊はまるで城のように作られていました。 Kanazawa Castle is still one of the most famous symbols of Kanazawa City, Ishikawa Prefecture. The castle is located on the edge of the Kodachino Plateau sticking out to the Kanazawa Plain between Saigawa River and Asano-gawa River. This site was first used as the grounds for Oyama-Gobo Temple where the followers of the Ikko Sect lived like the former Osaka Castle in the 16th Century of Sengoku Period. Kaga Province (what is now Ishikawa Prefecture) was called “a country owned by peasants” at that time, and the temple was designed to look like a castle.
城の位置~The location of the castle
城周辺の起伏地図~The relief map around the castle
しかしながら後に、この百姓たちは1580年に有力な戦国大名、織田信長によって滅ぼされて、御坊は破壊されてしまいます。信長は配下の佐久間盛政を送り込み、御坊の跡地に金沢城を築かせました。城は最終的には1583年に、前田氏の始祖、前田利家のものとなります。前田氏は、徳川幕府により100万石の収量がある加賀藩の領有を許されました。江戸時代を通じて最大の藩でした。 Later on, however, the peasants were defeated by a great warlord, Nobunaga Oda, in 1580 and the temple was destroyed. He sent his man, Morimasa Sakuma to build Kanazawa Castle on the ruin of the temple. The castle was last owned by Toshiie Maeda, the founder of the Maeda Clan in 1583. The clan was granted the Kaga Domain, also earning one million koku of rice, by the Tokugawa Shogunate, which was the biggest domain throughout the Edo Period.
前田氏が城を拡張して維持~Maeda Clan develops and maintains Castle
前田氏は、城を拡張し、いくつもの曲輪を築きました。最も高い所にある「本丸」、二番目に高い「二の丸」、そして低い所の「三の丸」などです。大きな水堀である「百閒堀」は、城と、城の弱点の一つであった台地の山側との間に掘られました。「総構え」と呼ばれる最も外側にある土塁が、台地上にある城を取り囲んでいる平地に築かれました。 The clan developed the castle building into several enclosures, with the highest enclosure being the the Main Enclosure or “Honmaru”, the second highest being the Second Enclosure or “Ninomaru”, then the Third Enclosure or “Sannnomaru” below, and so on. A large water moat called “Hyakken-Bori” was dug between the castle and the mountain side of the plateau which was one of the weak points of the castle. The outermost earthen walls of the castle called “So-gamae” were built on the plain area surrounding the castle on the plateau.
本丸上には、天守も築かれましたが、1602年に落雷により焼失してしまいました。その後、城は火災に何度も襲われました。前田氏は、その度に城を修復しましたが、城の姿は少しずつ変わっていきました。例えば、1631年の火災の後は、城の中心部は本丸から、二の丸にある二の丸御殿に移りました。1759年の火災の後には、「大手門」は再建されませんでした。元通りとなった河北門が代わって城の正門となりました。 The Main Tower was also built on the Main Enclosure, but it was struck by lightning and burned down in 1602. After that, the castle suffered from fires several times. The Maeda Clan restored the castle each time, but the appearance of the castle changed little by little. For example, after the fire in 1631, the center portion moved from the Main Enclosure to the Ninomaru Main Hall on the Second Enclosure. After the fire in 1759, the Main Gate or “Ote-mon” was not rebuilt. The restored Kahoku-mon Gate became the front gate of the castle instead.
前田氏による城の特色~Maeda Clan also develops Features
前田氏が江戸時代を通して城に住み、修復し続けたことにより、城には興味深い特徴が備わっていきました。一つは様々な石垣です。前田氏は、火災や他の災害で被災した石垣を、その時々の最新の技術やスタイルにより再建しました。その結果、城は「石垣の博物館」と言われるようになりました。 As the Maeda Clan continued to live in and repair the castle all through the Edo Period, the castle developed interesting features. One of them is the variety of stone walls. The clan rebuilt the stone walls which were damaged by fires and other accidents using the latest technologies and style of each time period. As a result, the castle has been called “a museum for stone walls”.
一方、石垣の上の多くの建物には、海鼠壁(四角い瓦を盛り上げた漆喰により連結して覆ったもの)、白い鉛瓦、出窓が付いた櫓といった共通の意匠上の特徴があります。これらにより城の建物はとても美しくなっています。 On the other hand, the many buildings on these stone walls had common design features such as Namako-kabe wall (covered with square tiles joined with raised plaster), white lead roof tiles, and bay window style turrets. These features made the castle buildings very beautiful.
特徴~Features
城周辺の航空写真~The aerial photo around the castle
石川門~Ishikawa-mon Gate
現在、金沢城は金沢城公園として一般に公開されています。その全周は2.2kmですが、高さ(約40m)があるためもっと大きく見えます。公園にはいくつか入口がありますが、最も有名なのは、城の3つある現存建物のうちの一つ、石川門です。この門は城の裏門だったのですが、やがて金沢城三御門の一つになりました。この門は、これも前田氏が造営した有名な庭園、兼六園の反対側にあります。かつては百間堀があった道路にかかった橋を渡って門に入ることができます。この門の構造は桝形門と言われていて、敵を防ぐ強力な防御力を得るために櫓や石垣で囲まれた四角い空間から成りたっていました。また、この門では、再築された時期が異なることによる複数のタイプの石垣を見ることができ、とても面白いものです。 Now, Kanazawa Castle is open to the public as Kanazawa Castle Park. Its perimeter is 2,2km, but it looks much larger because of its height (up to about 40m). The park has several gates, and the most popular one is the Ishikawa-mon Gate which is one of the three remaining buildings in the castle. The gate is the back gate of the castle, and eventually became one of the three important gates in the castle. It is located opposite to a famous garden called Kenrokuen which the Maeda Clan also created. You can go across the bridge over the road, where the Hyakken-bori moat once existed, to enter the gate. The structure of the gate is called Masugata-mon style which has a square space surrounded by turrets and walls to provide strong protection against enemies. The gate also has different types of stone walls because some parts of the walls were rebuilt several times. They look very interesting.
復元された建物群~Group of Restored Buildings
門の内側は三の丸で、河北門が右側に見え、橋詰門、五十間長屋、そして菱櫓が左側に見えます。これらは全て最近になって復元されました。河北門、橋詰門は金沢城三御門の残りの二つです。三の丸から見る河北門は、門の内側です。この門の正面は、新丸という更に低い位置の曲輪に面していて、ここには大手門がありました。橋詰門などは二の丸にあって、かつては曲輪を守っていました。この曲輪には二の丸御殿がありましたが、今は広場になっています。 The inside of the gate is the Third Enclosure where you can see Kahoku-mon Gate on the right, and Hashizume-mon Gate with Gojukken-nagaya Row House and Hishi Turret on the left. They have all been restored recently. These gates are two of the rest of the three important gates. What you see of Kahoku-mon Gate from the Third Enclosure is its back side. The front side of the gate faces a lower enclosure called Shinmaru which had the Main Gate. Hashizume-mon Gate, etc., are on the Second Enclosure, and protected its entrance in the past. The inside of the enclosure once had the Ninomaru Main Hall, but is a square now.
本丸周辺~Around Main Enclosure
本丸へは三の丸、二の丸両方から行くことができます。三の丸からは、東丸を通過して登っていきます。ここには、この城では最も古い石垣の一つと、現存する鶴丸倉庫があります。本丸は、城では最も高い位置にあり、早くに放置されたためか、林のようにも見えます。本丸の端からは、街並みを望むことができます。ここにはかつて30m近い高石垣がありましたが、明治時代に崩壊してしまいました。同じ場所で現在見ることができる階段状の石垣は、日本陸軍によって再建されたものです。 You can go to the Main Enclosure from both the Third and Second Enclosures. From the Third Enclosure, you will walk up to the Main Enclosure through the Higashi-maru Enclosure. Here you can see one of the oldest stone walls in the castle and the remaining “Tsurumaru” Warehouse. The Main Enclosure is the highest point of the castle and looks like a forest probably because it was abandoned earlier. You can see a town view from the edge of the enclosure. It once had nearly 30m high stone walls which collapsed in 1907 during the Meiji Era. The terraced stone walls we see now at the same place have been rebuilt by the Japanese Army.
二の丸と本丸の間には、「極楽橋」という橋が渡されており、その名前の由来は尾山御坊の時代に遡るといいます。極楽は仏教徒にとっての天国のことです。本丸のこの橋の近くには、残りの現存建物である三十間長屋があります。金沢城の3つの現存建物はいずれも重要文化財に指定されています。 Between the Second and Main Enclosures, you can go across a bridge called “Gokuraku-bashi” which derived its name from the period of Oyama-Gobo from the Ikko Sect Buddhists. Gokuraku means Buddhists’ Paradise. Near the bridge on the Main Enclosure, there is the other remaining building called Sanjukken Row House. The three remaining buildings in Kanazawa Castle are all designated as Important Cultural Properties.
その後~Later History
明治維新後、金沢城は日本陸軍によって使われました。金沢は軍都となり、市民の10%(2万人)が軍と関係がありました。城にある軍の遺跡としては、石垣、トンネル、第7旅団司令部建物などを現在見ることができます。ところが、今残っている3棟を除く元からあった全ての城の建物は、1881年の火災により焼けてしまいます。 After the Meiji Restoration, Kanazawa Castle was used for the Japanese Army. Kanazawa became a military base where about 10% of citizens (20,000) were associated with the military. We can now see the ruins of the military in the castle such as stone walls, tunnels and the building for the Headquarters of the 7th Brigade. However, all the original castle buildings were unfortunately destroyed by the fire in 1881, except for the three remaining buildings.
第二次世界大戦後、1949年から1995年まで、城は金沢大学として使われました。1996年以来、石川県は歴史公園として整備を進めています。伝統的建物を復元している中で、県は公園の名前を、金沢城址公園から金沢城公園と改めました。最近、石川門の反対側にあり、市街地に近い「鼠多門」という門が2020年7月に復元されました。これで、城を訪れ、楽しむことがもっと容易にできるようになりました。行政側は今、二の丸御殿を復元できるかどうか検討しています。 After World War II, the castle was used for Kanazawa University between 1949 and 1995. Since 1996, Ishikawa Prefecture has been developing it as a historical park. While restoring the traditional buildings, the prefecture renamed the park from Kanazawa Castle Ruins Park to Kanazawa Castle Park. One of the castle gates called “Nezumita-mon”, on the opposite side of Ishikawa-mon Gate, near the town area, was restored recently in July 2020. This made it easier for people to visit and enjoy the castle more. Officials are also considering if they should restore the Ninomaru Main Hall now.
1970年代の城周辺の航空写真~The aerial photo of the area around the castle in the 1970s
私の感想~My Impression
公園の名前の変更は、行政側の大変な努力と、日本の歴史を伝え、観光を盛り上げようとする決意を表しています。伝統的建物を復元し維持していくには多額の予算を必要とします。更にこのような建物の使用は、法律により厳しく制限されています。よって、建物の用途はほとんど観光のためということになるでしょう。余計なお世話かもしれませんが、少し心配です。この挑戦がこの先成功するよう望みます。 The renaming of the park shows the officials’ unusual effort and determination to preserve the history of Japan and increase tourism. Restoring and maintaining traditional buildings requires a huge budget. In addition, the uses for such buildings are strictly limited by law. That means these buildings are mostly for tourism. Counting others’ money is not my business, but I am a little concerned about it. I hope their challenge will be successful in the future.
ここに行くには~How to get There
車で行かれる場合は、北陸自動車道の金沢森本ICから約20分かかります。公園周辺にいくつか駐車場があります。 If you want to go there by car, it takes about 20 minutes from the Kanazawa-morimoto IC on Hokuriku Expressway. There are several parking lots around the park. 鉄道を使う場合は、金沢駅から、北陸鉄道バスか金沢循環バスに乗って、兼六園下バス停で降りてください。そこから歩いて約5分です。 When using the train, take the Hokuriku-tetsudo bus, Kanazawa Loop bus, or Kenrokuen Shuttle from Kanazawa Station, and get off at the Kenrokuen-shita stop. It takes about 5 minutes from the stop on foot.