93.Hitoyoshi Castle Part1

The early stage of Hitoyoshi Castle was much larger than its later stage during the Edo Period which is what we call the castle ruins.

Location and History

Sagara Clan governs Hitoyoshi area long

Hitoyoshi Castle was located beside the Kumagawa River in the Hitoyoshi Basin in the southern part of Higo Province which is modern day Kumamoto Prefecture. The Sagara Clan, the builder of the castle was first sent to the Hitoyoshi area by the Kamakura Shogunate around 1200. They lived in their residence on a flat square space, surrounded by moats, in the area like other lords in other areas at that time used to do such as the Ashikaga Clan Hall. Some consider this is the origin of Hitoyoshi Castle, however, the residence was built in a different place and ways from the castle which would be built later on. The clan had continued to govern the area since their settlement and the government was allowed by the shogunate and the governor of the province, the Kikuchi Clan. The square residence was moved and rebuilt at least once, but it became a holy place where important ceremonies like recruitements for the clan were held.

The range of Higo Province and the location of the castle

The portrait of Nagayori Sagara, the founder of the clan, drawn in the Edo Period, owned by Sagara Shrine (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

The location of the first residence of the Sagara Clan

Ashikaga Clan Hall

Nagatsugu Sagara builds Castle after his Overthrowing

However, it was not enough for them to maintain their territory and decide who would be their next successor. They were finally done by power and battles. In the middle of the 15th Century, Nagashige Nagatomi, a relative of the Sagara Clan, overthrew his superiors when the Bunan Internal Troubles happened and eventually became the lord of the clan, and he renamed it Nagatsugu Sagara. He first lived in Yamada Castle, a small mountain castle, located in the north of the previous lord’s residence. Then, he built and moved to Taka Castle which had several enclosures on the Shirasu plateau, near the residence, as he got more powerful. He probably made his retainers live in these enclosures to prepare for his taking over. It wss thought that he finally built Hitoyoshi Castle at the current place when he succeeded.

The transition of the home bases of Nagashige Nagatone

Hitoyoshi Castle was built along the southern side of the Kumagawa River in a similar way to that of Taka Castle on the Shirasu plateau, but was much larger than it. In fact, the early stage of Hitoyoshi Castle was also much larger than its later stage during the Edo Period which is what we call the castle ruins. The early one was actually a group of local castles, such as Uehara-jo, Nakahara-jo, Shimohara-jo, Nishino-maru, Sotomawari, and Uchi-jo. Each local castle was on one hill of the plateau which was separated from the others by dry moats. The lord of the clan lived in Uehara-jo which was the highest and largest castle among the group. An interesting thing about Uehara-jo was that it included the square space surrounded by its own moats which had been considered as the holy space for the clan. The important ceremonies seemed to continue to be held in the same space, which meant even the powerful new lord still wanted to follow the clan’s tradition and authority.

A distant view of Hitoyoshi Castle Ruins beside Kumagawa River

The relief map of the early Hitoyoshi Castle

Sagara Clan’s Success and Failure

The increasing force of the Sagara Clan flew out from the Hitoyoshi area to other areas in Higo Province. In particular, they wanted to get the Yatsushiro area beside the Yatsushiro Sea, which prospered from trading internationally. Nagatsugu’s son, Tametsugu started to invade the Yatsushiro area. Yoshishige, four generations after Tametsugu completed it and moved his home base from Hitoyoshi Castle to Furufumoto Castle which was called Yatsushiro Castle in 1534. The clan became one of the greatest warlords in the Kyushu Region and traded with foreign countries through the Ryukyu Kingdom, directly with the Ming Dynasty of China and even by smuggling. As a result, Hitoyoshi Castle was renovated as a branch castle of the clan. The Uchijo portion, which was used for the lord’s family residence, became the new lord’s residence which was called Miuchi.

The portrait of Yoshishige Sagara, the founder of the clan, owned by Sagara Shrine (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
The ruins of Furufumoto Castle, quoted from the website of Yatsushiro City

However, the Shimazu Clan, which aimed to invade all of the Kyushu Region in the late 16th Century, forced the Sagara Clan to surrender and hand Yatsushiro Castle over to the Shimazu Clan. The Sagara Clan had to return to Hitoyoshi Castle but was able to maintain it and their territory while the unification of Japan by Hideyoshi Toyotomi and the Tokugawa Shogunate was happening. Hitoyoshi Castle was reduced to the Miuchi area and the other parts were abandoned. Instead, the remaining area was modernized such as by building stone walls.

Hitoyoshi Castle was drawn in the Edo Period in “The illustration of Kuma Castle in Higo Province”, exhibited by the National Diet Library Digital Collections
The current Hitoyoshi Castle Ruins

The Sagara Clan governed the castle and the area around all through the Edo Period as the Hitoyoshi Domain. There were some problems in the domain during the long period. For example, an internal comflict, called Oshita Rebellion, happened in 1640. A senior vassal, Seibe Sagara, who got the power to be equal to the lord among the domain, was banished by the lord. His relatives were besieged in their residences, called Oshita-yashiki, but were defeated and the residences were also burned down. There was a great fire called Torasuke Fire in 1862, which caused many of the castle to burn down. After that, some of the stone walls were restored using a new method called Hanedashi which emulated the European castles.

The Hanedashi stone walls of Hitoyoshi Castle

To be continued in “Hitoyoshi Castle Part2”

190.Yatsushiro Castle Part1

There were three Yatsushiro Castles.

Location and History

First Yatsushiro Castle is targeted by several Lords

Yatsushiso City in Kumamoto Prefecture is known for an agricultural and industrial area in the western part of Kyushu Region. These industries have been developed on the reclaimed land since the Edo Period. People in Yatsushiro tripled the size of Yatsushiro Plain by draining water from the Yatsushiro Sea. Before the land reclamation, Yatsushiro prospered as a junction for land and water transportation. Yatsushiro Castle was originally located near the sea, which could control the transportation.

The range of Yatsushiro City and the location of the castle

In fact, there were three Yatsushiro Castles in history, which were originally named Furufumoto, Mugishima, and Matsue Castles. They also didn’t exist at the same time, so people called the most representative castle in the area, Yatsushiro Castle. If you look into the histories of the three castles, you will see that many of Yatsushiro City. Furufumoto Castle, as the first Yatsushiro Castle, was a typical mountain castle which was located on a hilly area between the 14th and 16th centuries. A local lord, the Nawa Clan governed the castle, while the Sagara Clan, which lived in Hitoyoshi Castle inland, wanted to invade Yatsusiro which is located in a good area. The Sagara Clan attacked Furufumoto Castle several times, and managed to finally capture it in 1504. However, during the process of the unification of Japan in the late 16th Century, the castle was followed by the Shimazu Clan and Hideyoshi Toyotomi in 1587.

The relief map around the castle

The ruins of Furufumoto Castle, quoted from the website of Yatsushiro City

Second Yatsushiro Castle becomes important place for Water Transportation

Hideyoshi sent his retainer, Yukinaga Konishi as the lord of southern Higo Proveince (Higo is almost the same as Kumamoto Pref.). He abandoned Furufumoto Castle and built Mugishima Castle instead, as the second Yatsushiro Castle. The castle was built at the estuary of Kumagawa River, facing the Yatsushiro Sea, to be used for water transportation. One of the reasons for its location was the preparation for the invasion of Korea that Hideyoshi had planned. Yukinaga actually became a vanguard of the invasion in 1592. In addition to its location, the castle was all made using stone walls. This castle was said to be the prototype of the last Yatsushiro Castle that we can see now. After the Battle of Sekigahara in 1600 where Yukinaga lost, Higo Province was followed by the Kato Clan. Their home base was Kumamoto Castle, while Mugishima Castle was owned by their senior vassal, Masakata Kato as a branch castle.

The excavation site of Mugishima Castle (licensed by Emeraldgreen at Japanese Wikipedia via Wikimedia Commons)
The portrait of Masakata Kato, owned by Joshinji Temple (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)

In 1615, the Tokugawa Shogunate issued the Law of One Castle per Province. All the branch castles in Higo Province were destroyed except for Mugishima Castle which was spared for some reasons. The reason for this exemption has been discussed a lot, but not finalized. One theory says that the lord of the clan, Tadahiro Kato was still very young, so the shogunate thought he would be supported by the senior vassal with Mugishima Castle as a guardian. The castle unfortunately collapsed in 1619 due to an earthquake. However, the castle was allowed to be rebuilt to another place as the next exemption. Or, it was said to be officially just move to another location. Anyway, Masakata was practically able to build a new castle nearby, once called Matsue Castle, now called (the third) Yatsushiro Castle.

The portrait of Tadahiro Kato, owned by Honmyoji Temple (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
Part of the illustration of the enclosures of Yatsushiro Castle in Higo Province, exhibited by the National Archives of Japan, This castle was also built near the estuary the sea

Third Yatsushiro Castle is built and survives as Exemption

The new castle was built partially using Mugishima Castle’s design and materials. For example, the four-level Main Tower was build at the corner of the Main Enclosure, which is an old style of castles built in Toyotomi’s period. On the other hand, the castle used an advanced defensive system called Masugata. Masgata refers to a square shaped space which is surrounded by stone walls at a castle’s entrance. The Masugata system of the castle was set slightly overhanging from the outer line of the Main Entrance, which could counterattack the enemies’ sides. This could be considered as the final version of the system. The castle was eventually completed in 1622.

The picture of the miniature model of Yatsushiro Castle’s main portion, from the signboard at the site
The Main Tower was built at the corner, form the signboard at the site
A Masugata system of Yatsushiro Castle, hanging out from its Main Enclosure

The Kato Clan was unfortunately fired by the shogunate in 1632 before the Hosokawa Clan followed Higo Province. The clan still used Kumamoto Castle as their home base, then Yatsushiro Castle was used as the retreat for the lord’s father, Sansai Hosokawa. He was a survivor of the Sengoku Period and had a self-willed character. That seemed to be another reason that the shogunate couldn’t force to abandon the castle. Sansai even planned to be an independent lord with the castle before his death. As a result, the castle managed to survive all through the Edo Period. The castle was finally owned by the Matsui Clan, a senior vassal of the Kumamoto Domain by the Hosokawa Clan.

The portrait of Sansai Hosokawa, owned by Eisei Bunko Museum (licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons)
Kumamoto Castle
The ruins of Yatsushiro Castle

To be continued in “Yatsushiro Castle Part2”

92.熊本城(Kumamoto Castle)

次の地震に備えるためにはどうすればよいのでしょうか?
What should be the plan to be prepared for the next earthquake?

熊本城の天守(The Tenshu keep of Kumamoto Castle)taken by さてらいと from photoAC

何が起こったか~What happened?

2016年に熊本地震が起きてから3年以上経過しました。この地震により熊本県には甚大な被害が発生し、熊本城も同様でした。城にとって最も深刻だったのが、50か所に渡り石垣が崩壊したことでした。石垣の崩壊により、多くの建物が倒壊したり、破損または深刻な状態に陥りました。現存する日本の城壁の中では一番長く、重要文化財に指定されている長塀は、全長242mのうち80mが崩壊しました。
Over 3 years have passed since the 2016 Kumamoto Earthquakes. They caused great damage to the area in Kumamoto Prefecture including Kumamoto Castle. For the castle, the most serious factor could be the collapse of stone walls in 50 points. With the collapse, many buildings were either torn down, were broken or are in critical condition. The Long Wall, the longest among the remaining castle walls in Japan, designated as an important cultural property, collapsed over 80m out of 242m in total.

地震前の長塀(The Long Wall before the earthquakes)licensed by DryPot via Wikimedia Commons
修理中の長塀、2019年6月時点(The Long Wall under repair in June, 2019)

もう一つの重要文化財である東十八間櫓は、石垣とともに完全に倒壊しました。
Another important cultural property, Higashi-Juhakken Turret also torn down completely with stone walls.

地震前の東十八間櫓(Higashi-Juhakken Turret before the earthquakes)lisencesd by Reggaeman via Wikimedia Commons
東十八間櫓は跡形もありません、2017年12月時点(Higashi-Juhakken Turret disappeared without trace, taken in December,2017)

最近復元された建物もまた被害を受けました。特に飯田丸五階櫓は、わずかに片隅の石垣によって支えられている「奇跡の一本石垣」として注目されました。
Recently restored building also suffered, in particular, Iidamaru-five-layer-turret was focused on for being supported by only one corner stone to survive, known as “the miracle lone stone walls”.

飯田丸五階櫓と一本石垣、2016年7月時点、現在は再建のため一旦撤去されている(Iidamaru-five-layer-turret and the miracle lone stone walls in July,2016. They were once demolished to reconstruct in the future.)産経フォトより引用

乾櫓も同じような状況でした。
Inui-turret has had a similar situation.

乾櫓、2017年12月時点(Inui Turret in December, 2017)
乾櫓石垣の状態、2017年12月時点(The state of Inui Turret’s stone walls)

1960年に現代の工法で外観復元された天守も被害を免れませんでした。ほとんどの屋根瓦が地震で剝げ落ちてしまったのです。
The Tenshu keep, which was apparently restored in the modern way in 1960, was not without suffering. Almost all of its roof tiles were peeled off by the earthquakes.

修理中の天守、2017年12月時点(The Tenshu keep under repair in December, 2017)

城の現存建物の中で最大の宇土櫓は、比較的少ない被害で済みました。この櫓の頑丈さが改めて認識されるとともに、地震の被害者をも勇気づけているとのことです。
Udo-turret, the largest remaining building in the castle had relatively small damage. People say that it has shown its strength and has encouraged victims of the earthquakes.

宇土櫓、2017年12月時点(Udo Turret in December, 2017)

熊本市長は、天守を修理するのに3年、城全体を元通りにするのに20年かかると言っていました。その通りに天守の復元はなされており、2019年10月から部分的に公開されています。
The mayor of Kumamoto City stated that it would take 3 years to fix the Tenshu, and 20 years would be needed to restore the castle completely. As he said, the restoration of Tenshu has been done, it has partly open since October 2019.

2019年9月時点の天守(The Tenshu keep in September, 2019)産経フォトより引用

立地と歴史~Location and History

熊本城は、現在の熊本市の丘陵地帯の端に位置する茶臼山の上にあります。この城は加藤清正が1588年に肥後(現在の熊本県)の国主として着任してきてから有名になりました。清正は、薩摩国(現在の鹿児島県)の島津氏の幕府への反逆を防ぐため、この城を強大に作り込みました。加藤氏が改易となった後、その後を継いだ細川氏も江戸時代を通じて大変な労力を投じて城を維持、拡張してきました。
Kumamoto Castle has been located on a mountain called Chausu-yama on the edge of the hilly area which is now Kumamoto City. The castle became famous since Kiyomasa Kato was placed as the lord of Higo Province (what is now called Kumamoto Pref.) in 1588. Kiyomasa built the castle so large and strong that it could avoid The Shimadu’s invasion from Satsuma Province (Kagoshima Pref.) against the Shogunate. The Hosokawa clan following kato’s position after they quit, continued to keep and develop the castle making great efforts all through the Edo Period.


城周辺の起伏地図(The relief map around the castle)

加藤清正像、本妙寺蔵、江戸時代(The portrait of Kiyomasa Kato in Edo Period, owned by Honmyoji Temple)licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons

明治維新後、この城は日本陸軍の九州地方の根拠地となり、「鎮西鎮台」と呼ばれました。1877年に予期もしていなかった戦いが政府軍と西郷隆盛率いる薩摩反乱軍との間で起こりました。この戦いは「西南戦争」と呼ばれ、日本最後の内戦であるとともに、政府による徴兵と西郷指揮下の元武士との戦いであるとも見なされました。
After the Meiji Restoration, the castle was turned to into a Japanese Army base in Kyushu region called “Chinzei Chindai”. An unexpected battle happened between the Government Army and the Satusma Rebel Army led by Takamori Saigo in 1877. It was called “the Seinan War”, which was the last civil war in Japan, and also regarded as a battle between drafted soldiers under the Government and former warriors under Saigo.

西郷隆盛像、エドアルド・キヨッソーネ作(The portrait of Takamori Saigo by Edoardo Chiossonelicensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons

熊本城が実際の戦いに使われたのはこれが最初だったのです。西郷は城を包囲したのですが、この間天守を含む多くの建物が失火により焼けてしまいました。しかし城の中の兵隊たちは、政府からの援軍が到着するまで耐え忍び、ついに西郷は撤退しました。武士の世が終わってからの近代戦においてさえ、この城が強力であることが証明されたのです。城跡は最終的には1931年に国の史跡に指定されました。
That was the first time that Kumamoto Castle was used for actual fighting. Saigo surrounded the castle while many of the buildings including the Tenshu keep were burned accidentally. But the soldiers in the castle survived until the reinforcements from the Government arrived before Saigo withdrew. Even the modern war prove the strength of the castle after warriors’ governance ended. The ruins was finally designated as a National Historic Site in 1931.

谷干城少将に率いられた鎮西鎮台の指揮官たち、朝日百科より(The commanders of Chinzei Chindai led by General Tateki Tani, from Asahi encyclopedia)licensed under Public Domain via Wikipedia Commons

これからどうなる?~What will happen?

なぜ復元にそんなに時間がかかるかというと、熊本城が文化財だからです。例えば、崩壊した石垣の場合では、一つ一つの石は元の場所に戻されなければなりません。それぞれの石の3次元データを登録し、以前の写真と照合し、位置を確定するのです。更には、石垣を復元するのは元の伝統的工法でなければなりません。それができる企業や職人は限られています。またそれには莫大な予算も必要です。
The reason why the restoration takes so long time is mainly the castle being a cultural property. For example. In case of collapsing stone walls, each stone must be returned to the original position. Its 3-dimensional shapes are registered and checked with old pictures to match the position. In addition, restoring stone walls is required to build in the original traditional way. There are also few companies and craftsmen who can do it. it will also require huge funds.

復元を待つ石たち、2017年12月時点(Stones waitng for being restored in December, 2017)

私の意見~My Opinion

私は最近現場を見て回りましたが、復元にそんなにも時間がかかることは理解できました。しかし、もしまた地震が起こったらどうするのでしょうか?清正は、あの有名な「武者返し」と呼ばれる石垣のカーブを地震による崩壊を防ぐために作ったのだと言う科学者がいます。
I looked around the site recently and also realized that the restoration would take such a long time. But what should be the plan if another earthquake happens? Some scientists say that Kiyomasa might have created the famous curve of the stone walls called “Musha-Gaeshi” to prevent it from collapse by an earthquake.

熊本城の「武者返し」の石垣と天守(The stone walls called “Musha-Gaeshi” with Tenshu)taken by ichico from photoAC

江戸時代初期のこの城の城主だった細川忠利は、余分な建物を撤去し、次来る地震に備えて「地震屋」と呼ばれる避難所を建てました。
Tadatoshi Hosokawa, a lord of the castle in the early Edo Period, removed extra buildings and built a refuge shelter called “jishinya” to be prepared for the next earthquake.

細川忠利肖像画、矢野吉重筆、永青文庫蔵(The portrait of Tadatoshi Hosokawa, attributed to Yoshishige Yano, owned by Eisei Bunko Musemu)licensed under Public Domain via Wikimedia Commons

たとえ今は文化財であっても、元々のやり方が常にベストとは限りません。熊本市は、大きな地震が発生したときにも安全であるよう、長期的に城の新しい復元手法を開発するとのことです。それが早く実現するよう願ってやみません。
Even if the castle is now a cultural property, the original way is not always the best. Kumamoto City says that they will develop new methods for restoring the castle in the long term to be safe when a large earthquake happens. I really hope it will work in practice soon.

宇土櫓と修理中の天守、2017年12月時点(Udo Turret, and Tenshu under repair in December, 2017)

ここに行くには~How to get There

熊本駅から:
熊本市電を使うときは、熊本駅前電停から熊本城・市役所前電停まで乗ります。約17分かかります。
バスを使うときは、熊本駅前バス停から桜町バスターミナルまで乗ります。約10分かかります。
From Kumamoto Station:
When using Kumamoto City Tram, take the tram from Kumamoto-Eki-Mae tram stop to Kumamotojo-Shiyakusho-Mae tram stop. It takes about 17 minutes.
When using Bus, take it from Kumamoto-Eki-Mae bus stop to Sakuramachi bus terminal. It takes about 10 minutes.

リンク、参考情報~Links and Rererences

熊本城公式サイト(Kumamoto Castle Official Website)
・「復興熊本城Vol.2 天守復興編Ⅰ 平成30年度上半期まで」熊本日日新聞社(Japanese Book)
・「熊本城の被災修復と細川忠利」後藤典子著、熊日新書(Japanese Book)
・「歴史群像2016年8月号/壮烈!熊本城攻防戦」学研プラス(Japanese Magazine)
・「BS1スペシャルよみがえれ熊本城 サムライの英知を未来へ」NHK、2017年(Japanese TV Program)